What’s the Difference Between a Trustee and a NED?

The difference between a trustee and a NED — charity vs company governance, the Charities Act vs Companies Act, paid vs unpaid, and where the roles overlap.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Fintech Non-Executive Recruitment

What’s the Difference Between a Trustee and a NED?

What’s the Difference Between a Trustee and a NED?

Trustee and non-executive director are often mentioned in the same breath, and for good reason. Both are board roles held by people who do not run the organisation day to day. Both exist to provide oversight, challenge and judgement. Both attract experienced people who want to contribute their skills at board level, and many people hold one of each at different points in their careers. Yet the two roles are not interchangeable. The legal framework, the accountability, the question of pay and the practical experience of the boardroom can all be quite different.

This guide sets out the distinction clearly, using the UK framework that governs each role. It is written for people weighing up a first board seat, for serving directors considering a charity board, and for chairs and chief executives deciding what kind of board member their organisation needs. If you are new to board roles altogether, our guide to what a non-executive director is is a good place to start.

The Short Answer

A trustee sits on the governing body of a charity. Their role is to make sure the charity pursues its charitable purposes for the public benefit and uses its resources properly. They are regulated, in England and Wales, by the Charity Commission under the Charities Act 2011, and they are usually unpaid.

A non-executive director sits on the board of a company. Their role is to provide independent oversight of the executive team and to help the board promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members. They owe the general duties set out in the Companies Act 2006, and they are normally paid a fee.

The two can overlap. Many charities are set up as companies limited by guarantee, and in those charities every trustee is also a company director. A person can therefore be a trustee and a director at the same time, carrying both sets of duties.

The Core Distinction: Charity Versus Company

The simplest way to hold the difference in mind is to start with the type of organisation each role governs. Almost everything else follows from that.

A charity exists to advance purposes that the law recognises as charitable, such as relieving poverty, advancing education or protecting health, and it must do so for the public benefit. Its assets are held for those purposes, not for the benefit of owners. The trustee’s job is to keep the charity on course towards its purposes and to protect what it holds for its beneficiaries.

A company, by contrast, is usually run for the benefit of its shareholders. Directors must promote its success for the benefit of its members as a whole, while having regard to employees, customers, suppliers, the community and the long term. The non-executive’s job is to bring independent judgement to that task: testing strategy, scrutinising performance, overseeing risk and holding the executive team to account. Our guide to NED responsibilities and legal duties describes that role in more detail.

Different Legal Frameworks

The trustee’s duties

The Charity Commission’s core guidance for trustees, The Essential Trustee (CC3), summarises a trustee’s responsibilities as six main duties. As the NCVO’s summary sets out, trustees must:

  • ensure the charity is carrying out its purposes for the public benefit;
  • comply with the charity’s governing document and the law;
  • act in the charity’s best interests, including avoiding conflicts of interest;
  • manage the charity’s resources responsibly;
  • act with reasonable care and skill; and
  • ensure the charity is accountable.

These duties are collective. Trustees act together as a board, and decisions are made by the trustees as a body rather than by any individual. The Charity Commission can investigate concerns, open inquiries, remove trustees and take other regulatory action where things go wrong.

The non-executive director’s duties

A company director, executive or non-executive, owes the general duties in Part 10 of the Companies Act 2006. These include the duty to act within the company’s powers, to promote its success, to exercise independent judgement, to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence, to avoid conflicts of interest, not to accept benefits from third parties and to declare interests in transactions. Company law makes no distinction between executive and non-executive directors: the same duties apply to both, although what is reasonably expected of a NED reflects their role. Our article on the legal duties of a non-executive director works through each one, and directors’ duties under the Companies Act 2006 covers the statutory text.

NEDs in listed companies also work within the UK Corporate Governance Code, and NEDs in FCA-regulated firms may hold senior manager functions under the SMCR. Neither of those regimes applies to trustees as such, although charities have their own voluntary code, discussed below.

Accountability: Who Each Role Answers To

A NED is accountable to the company’s shareholders. Shareholders appoint and can remove directors, and in listed companies directors usually stand for re-election every year. Investors, lenders and, in regulated sectors, the FCA or PRA all take an interest in how the board performs.

A trustee has no shareholders. They are accountable to the charity’s purposes and beneficiaries, to the charity’s members where it has them, and to the Charity Commission. That changes the feel of the role. There is no share price and no profit to measure success against, so trustees have to judge performance against the charity’s mission, its impact and its long-term sustainability, which is often harder.

Pay: The Most Visible Difference

The clearest practical difference is pay. Trustees are usually unpaid volunteers. Charity law starts from the position that trustees should not benefit from their charity, and a trustee can only be paid for serving as a trustee where there is proper legal authority for it, such as a clause in the governing document or the Commission’s consent. Trustees can normally be reimbursed for reasonable expenses, and there are limited statutory routes to pay a trustee for providing separate services to the charity, subject to conditions.

NEDs, by contrast, are normally paid a fee set by the board or the shareholders. Fees vary widely with the size and complexity of the organisation and the role, and committee chairs and senior independent directors often receive more. Our NED salary guide sets out typical ranges, and how NED fees are structured explains the options. NED fees are taxed as employment income, as our guide to NED fees and National Insurance explains.

Some larger charities, and many organisations that are not charities but have a public or social purpose, such as housing associations, NHS trusts and some public bodies, do pay their board members. In those cases the role often looks more like a NED role in practice, even if the title differs.

Where the Roles Overlap: Charitable Companies

Many charities are incorporated as charitable companies limited by guarantee. In those charities the trustees are also the company’s directors. They owe charity law duties as trustees and Companies Act duties as directors, and the charity reports both to the Charity Commission and to Companies House.

Other charities are charitable incorporated organisations (CIOs), a legal form created specifically for charities. A CIO gives trustees the protection of incorporation without making them company directors, and it registers only with the Charity Commission. Unincorporated charities, such as charitable trusts and associations, have no separate legal personality, which can leave trustees more personally exposed if things go wrong.

The practical point for anyone joining a charity board is to ask what legal form the charity takes, because it affects your duties, your reporting obligations and your personal exposure. Our article on NEDs on charity and not-for-profit boards explores what changes for an experienced company director who joins a charity board.

Liability and Insurance

Both roles carry real responsibility, but the risk profile differs. A company director can face personal liability for breach of duty, wrongful trading where a company continues to trade when insolvency was unavoidable, and a range of regulatory offences, and can be disqualified from acting as a director. Most companies protect their NEDs with directors’ and officers’ insurance and an indemnity, which our guide to D&O insurance for non-executive directors covers.

Trustees acting honestly and reasonably are rarely held personally liable, and incorporation as a charitable company or CIO generally protects them from the charity’s debts. But trustees of unincorporated charities can be personally exposed, and any trustee who acts outside their powers or in breach of trust can be required to make good a loss. Many charities buy trustee indemnity insurance, which charity law allows in defined circumstances.

Governance Codes

NEDs of companies listed in the equity shares (commercial companies) category work within the UK Corporate Governance Code, which sets expectations on independence, board balance, committees and evaluation on a comply-or-explain basis. Our guide to how the UK Corporate Governance Code impacts NEDs covers it, and what is corporate governance? places it in context.

Charities have their own voluntary Charity Governance Code, developed by the sector rather than the regulator. It sets out principles on organisational purpose, leadership, integrity, decision-making, board effectiveness, equality, diversity and inclusion, and openness and accountability, with separate versions for larger and smaller charities. It is not a legal requirement, but many charities use it as a benchmark and report against it.

The Experience in the Boardroom

Beyond the law, the two roles often feel different in practice. Charity boards frequently draw their members from a wider range of backgrounds, including people with lived experience of the charity’s cause, alongside professionals in finance, law, fundraising and operations. Meetings can involve more discussion of mission, values and impact, and trustees may be closer to the work of the charity than a NED is to a company’s operations, particularly in smaller charities with few staff.

Company boards tend to be more focused on financial performance, strategy, risk and the interests of investors. In private equity-backed and high-growth companies the pace can be fast and the board small. In listed companies, the formal structure of committees and Code reporting shapes much of the work.

Both roles demand the same core qualities: independence of mind, the confidence to challenge, good judgement and enough time to do the job properly. Our guide to NED skills, competencies and behaviours describes them, and much of it applies equally to trustees.

Moving From Trustee to NED: What Transfers

Trustee experience How it helps on a company board
Chairing a finance or audit committee Direct evidence for an audit committee role
Overseeing a chief executive The same skills of support and challenge
Managing risk and safeguarding Experience of risk oversight and accountability
Working with a regulator Familiarity with regulatory scrutiny
Fundraising and stakeholder work Experience of investors, funders and reputation

Jodie says

Present trustee work as board work

Candidates often list trustee roles at the bottom of their CV. We encourage them to describe it as board experience, with the decisions they contributed to, because that is exactly what commercial boards want to see.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Which Role Is Right for You?

For many people, a trustee role is the natural first step into board work. It offers experience of governance, strategy and collective decision-making, often in an area the person cares about, and it builds the track record that company boards look for. Boards recruiting a first-time NED regularly value charity board experience, as our article on what boards look for in first-time NEDs explains.

A paid NED role suits people who want to apply commercial or specialist expertise, are comfortable with the legal and financial responsibility that comes with a company directorship, and want board work to form part of a portfolio career. Many experienced directors hold both: one or two paid NED roles alongside a trustee role that reflects a personal interest. If you are weighing the options, our NED Career Hub brings our career guidance together, and NED vs trustee vs advisory board member adds a third option to the comparison.

Recruiting a Trustee or a NED

The recruitment process for the two roles is similar in outline: define the skills the board needs, write a clear role description, search widely, assess candidates on evidence and check independence, time and conflicts before appointing. The differences lie in the detail. Charity searches often need to reach candidates who have never held a board role and to be clear that the role is unpaid. Company searches need to consider fees, independence under the Code where it applies and any regulatory approval.

We run both kinds of search. See our trustee recruitment service and our guide to how to appoint a charity trustee, or browse current trustee roles. For company boards, see non-executive director recruitment and charity non-executive recruitment for paid board roles in the not-for-profit sector.

Trustee vs NED at a Glance

  • Organisation governed: a trustee governs a charity; a NED governs a company.
  • Main legal framework: charity law, including the Charities Act 2011, for trustees; the Companies Act 2006 for NEDs.
  • Regulator: the Charity Commission for trustees in England and Wales; for NEDs, depending on the company, Companies House, the FCA or PRA and the listing regime.
  • Accountable to: the charity’s purposes, beneficiaries and members for trustees; shareholders for NEDs.
  • Pay: usually unpaid for trustees, with expenses reimbursed; a fee for NEDs.
  • Governance code: the voluntary Charity Governance Code for trustees; the UK Corporate Governance Code for NEDs of listed companies.
  • Overlap: trustees of a charitable company are also company directors.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a charity trustee the same as a non-executive director?
No. Both are non-executive board roles, but a trustee governs a charity under charity law and a NED governs a company under company law. In a charitable company the trustees are also directors, so the roles combine.

Are charity trustees paid?
Usually not. Trustees can be reimbursed for reasonable expenses, but paying a trustee for serving as a trustee requires proper legal authority, such as a clause in the governing document or Charity Commission consent.

Can I be a trustee and a NED at the same time?
Yes. Many people hold a paid NED role alongside an unpaid trustee role. The main things to manage are time and any conflicts of interest between the organisations, both of which should be disclosed before appointment.

Does trustee experience help me get a NED role?
Often, yes. It shows you understand collective decision-making, governance and challenge. Boards hiring a first-time NED regularly value charity board experience alongside executive expertise.

Are trustees personally liable?
Trustees who act honestly and reasonably are rarely held personally liable, and incorporation as a charitable company or CIO usually protects them from the charity’s debts. Trustees of unincorporated charities can be more exposed, which is why many charities buy trustee indemnity insurance.

Do the same governance rules apply to both?
No. NEDs in listed companies work within the UK Corporate Governance Code, while charities can adopt the voluntary Charity Governance Code. Both codes share common themes of purpose, integrity, board effectiveness and accountability.

Related Guides and Services

Trustee and non-executive board roles.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors and trustees they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Appointing a Trustee or a Non-Executive Director?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to discuss a charity or company board appointment in confidence. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.