Why Use a NED Headhunter?

Find out why specialist NED headhunters deliver better board appointments than in-house searches or generalist recruiters. NED Capital UK. Call 0203 137 2496.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Why Use a NED Headhunter?

The Case for Using a NED Headhunter

Most boards running their first non-executive director search expect it to be simple: write a brief, advertise the role, interview the best applicants. Many discover that the approach produces a shortlist of people who are actively looking for a board seat, which is not the same as a shortlist of the people best suited to the role. The non-executive directors who would add most to a board are usually already serving on one or two boards, are selective about new mandates and do not answer adverts.

This article sets out the reasons boards use a specialist headhunter for non-executive and chair appointments, how that compares with running the search in-house or advertising, and when a headhunter is not necessary. If you want to know how we run a headhunted search in practice, see our NED headhunters page, which explains our method step by step.

Reason 1: The Best Candidates Are Not Applying

Executive recruitment works partly because many good executives are open to a move and watch the market. The non-executive market is different. Experienced chairs, committee chairs and non-executive directors are in demand, and the strongest of them choose new roles through their networks and through direct approaches they trust. An advert reaches the people who are actively searching, and it rarely reaches the person who has just stepped down as a FTSE finance director and is weighing up two board invitations.

A headhunter starts from the other end. Instead of waiting for applications, they identify the people who match the brief, including those who are not looking, and approach them directly. That changes the shape of the candidate pool rather than just its size. Our guide to the NED recruitment process for chairs explains why the research stage matters so much.

Reason 2: An Independent View of What the Board Needs

Boards are not always the best judges of their own gaps. A board that has worked together for years can default to looking for someone familiar, or to replacing the departing director like for like. A good headhunter challenges the brief before the search begins: what skills, sector knowledge and perspectives is the board missing, which committees need strengthening, and what will the business need from its board over the next three to five years?

That conversation often draws on a board skills matrix and, where it has been done, the findings of a recent independent board evaluation. A brief that is tested at the start produces a far more focused search and a shortlist that is easier to compare.

Reason 3: Independence and Conflicts Tested Early

A non-executive director’s value depends on their independence. A candidate who looks excellent on paper but has a business relationship with a major supplier, sits on a competitor’s board or is too close to a significant shareholder may not be able to do the job. A specialist headhunter checks other directorships, conflicts and time commitments in the first conversation, not at offer stage when a problem is far more disruptive.

For listed companies the tests in the UK Corporate Governance Code set the standard, and for regulated firms the regulator’s expectations add another layer. Our guides on why independence matters and what makes a board truly independent explain the principles.

Reason 4: Confidentiality on Both Sides

Board appointments are often sensitive. The board may not want staff, competitors or the market to know that a director is leaving, that a chair is being replaced or that the company is strengthening its board ahead of a transaction. Candidates, too, may not want their current boards to know they are considering another role. An advert makes confidentiality almost impossible.

A headhunter runs the search discreetly: the client can remain unnamed until a candidate has shown genuine interest and agreed to confidentiality, and candidates can explore the role without exposing themselves. For appointments made ahead of a sale, a listing or a restructuring, that discretion is often the deciding factor.

Reason 5: A Rigorous, Comparable Assessment

Assessing a non-executive director is different from assessing an executive. The board needs to know how a candidate behaves in a boardroom: whether they challenge constructively, how they handle disagreement with the chair or chief executive, whether they prepare thoroughly and whether they can contribute outside their own specialism. A specialist headhunter uses structured interviews against the agreed brief and takes board-level references from chairs and fellow directors, not just former line managers.

The result is a shortlist where each candidate has been assessed against the same criteria, so the board can compare them like for like. Our guide to how to appoint a non-executive director covers the selection stage in more detail.

Start a board search

Why Use a NED Headhunter? — 0203 137 2496

Non-executive directors, chairs, committee chairs and trustees for boards across the UK. Talk to Jodie Garrington and the team on 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk, and we will reply within one working day.

Tell us about your hireCall 0203 137 2496

Looking for a board role? Register as a candidate

Reason 6: Time and Focus for the Board

Running a search well takes a substantial amount of time: research, approaches, first conversations, interviews, referencing and negotiation. For a busy chair or nomination committee, that time comes on top of the normal demands of the board. A headhunter takes on the research and screening so that the board’s time goes into meeting a small number of well-matched candidates and making the decision.

Headhunter, In-House Search or Advert?

Advertising can work for some roles, particularly where transparency is expected, such as certain public appointments, or where the board wants to widen access to first-time candidates. It produces volume, but it rarely reaches serving directors, and it requires the board to sift and assess applicants itself.

An in-house search through the board’s own networks is quick and inexpensive, and it can find excellent people. The risk is that it draws from a narrow circle, tends to produce candidates who resemble the existing directors, and makes objective assessment and independence testing harder when the candidate is already known to the board.

A specialist headhunter combines research, direct approach and structured assessment. It costs more than the alternatives, but it gives the board access to candidates it would not otherwise reach and an independent view of who best fits the brief. For most chair and committee chair appointments, and for any appointment where the board needs a specific skill set or confidentiality, a headhunted search is usually the safer route. Our pages comparing NED recruitment agencies and non-executive recruitment consultants explain the different models in more detail.

What a Good Search Brief Contains

Section What it covers
Purpose Why the board is appointing and what the NED should achieve in the first year
Essential experience No more than three or four must-haves
Desirable experience Helpful but not decisive
Committees and time Which committees, and a realistic number of days
Fee and terms The annual fee, term and any equity
Process Who interviews, who decides and the timetable
Exclusions Competitors, conflicts or profiles the board does not want

Jodie says

The briefing is the most important hour

Most of a search’s success is decided at the briefing meeting. When the chair, and where relevant the investor, agree the purpose and the must-haves, the rest of the search goes far more smoothly.

We send a written brief back to the client after that meeting, so everyone can check we have understood before we approach anyone.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

When a Headhunter Is Not Necessary

A headhunter is not always the right answer. If the board already has a strong internal candidate whose independence is not in question, if a major investor has the right to nominate a director, or if the role is an advisory board seat rather than a statutory directorship, a full search may be unnecessary. Some boards also run an open process alongside a headhunted search to widen the pool. A good headhunter will tell you when a full search is not needed. Our guide to advisory boards versus NEDs may help if you are unsure which you need.

What to Look for in a NED Headhunter

Ask whether the firm specialises in board appointments or treats them as an extension of executive search. Ask how they will research the market and approach candidates, how they assess independence and boardroom behaviour, and who will run the search day to day. Ask whether they follow the voluntary code of conduct for executive search firms, how they approach diversity in the shortlist, and how the fee and timetable will be agreed before the search begins.

At NED Capital, searches are led by Jodie Garrington, with oversight from founder Adrian Lawrence FCA, drawing on the shared network of the five specialist firms in the FD Capital Group. We work only on board appointments, including non-executive directors, non-executive chairs, committee chairs and trustees. Fees and timetables are agreed before any search begins; our NED salary guide covers what directors are typically paid.

Related Board Search Services

Specialist search for every type of board appointment.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors and chairs they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept. NED Capital is one of five specialist firms in the FD Capital Group.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a NED headhunter worth the cost for a smaller company?
It depends on the role. For a first independent chair or a director with specific skills the board cannot find through its own network, a headhunted search usually pays for itself in the quality of the appointment. For an advisory role, a lighter approach may be enough.

Can we advertise and use a headhunter at the same time?
Yes. Some boards, particularly in the public and charity sectors, run an open advert alongside a headhunted search so that both applicants and directly approached candidates are assessed against the same brief.

Will a headhunter only put forward people they already know?
A good headhunter uses their network as a starting point, not a limit. Each search should involve fresh research into the market for that specific brief, including candidates the firm has not met before.

What is the difference between this page and your NED headhunters page?
This article explains why boards use a headhunter. Our NED headhunters page explains how we run a headhunted search.

Considering a Headhunted Board Search?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk through your board appointment in confidence. We cover London, the West Midlands and the whole of the UK from our offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.