What Makes a Board Truly Independent in Practice?

What board independence really means under the UK Corporate Governance Code, the factors that compromise it, and why it matters more in practice than on paper

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
What Makes a Board Truly Independent in Practice?

Most discussion of board independence starts and ends with the formal tests: how long a director has served, whether they used to work for the company, whether they have a business relationship with it or represent a major shareholder. Those tests matter. They identify the circumstances most likely to compromise a director’s judgement, and they are the basis on which listed companies report to investors. But they describe the conditions for independence, not independence itself.

Some of the most damaging governance failures have happened on boards that looked impeccably independent on paper. The directors met every test, the annual report said so, and yet the board accepted management’s account of the business without testing it. This guide is about that gap: what makes a board genuinely independent in the way it behaves, and how a chair, a nomination committee or an individual NED can tell whether it is.

We do not repeat the formal tests here. If you need them, our guide to the difference between an independent and a non-executive director sets out the UK position, and our article on non-executive vs independent director terminology explains how the terms are used in the US and EU. For the different kinds of non-independent director, see independent vs affiliated NEDs.

Formal Independence vs Independence of Mind

The UK Corporate Governance Code asks the board to identify which non-executive directors it considers independent, and lists circumstances that are likely to impair independence. It expects at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent non-executive directors. The 2024 Code makes no exception for smaller listed companies. Those rules set a floor for board composition, and they force boards to explain themselves when they depart from it.

Independence of mind is different. It is the willingness and ability to form a view on the evidence, to say so when that view differs from management’s, and to hold to it under pressure. It cannot be read from a director’s CV. Company law already expects it of every director: section 173 of the Companies Act 2006 requires each director to exercise independent judgement, whether or not the board classes them as independent.

The two kinds of independence support each other. A director with a close relationship to the CEO will find it harder to challenge, however principled they are. A director with no conflicts at all can still be ineffective if they are poorly informed, new to the sector, or simply reluctant to rock the boat. A truly independent board needs both: directors who are free of compromising ties, and a board culture in which they use that freedom.

What Independent Boards Do Differently

Independence shows up in behaviour. These are the patterns we see on boards that are independent in practice, and that are missing on boards that are independent only in name.

They ask questions that management has not anticipated

A dependent board asks the questions the board paper invites. An independent board asks what the paper leaves out: what alternatives were considered, what would have to be true for the plan to work, what the downside looks like, and what the executive team is worried about but has not said. Our guide to creating constructive tension in the boardroom covers how boards build this habit without becoming adversarial.

They are willing to say no, or not yet

Boards that never reject, defer or materially amend a management proposal are rarely exercising independent judgement. That does not mean independent boards are obstructive. Most proposals should be approved. But an independent board is comfortable sending a paper back for more work, approving a smaller first phase, or attaching conditions, and management knows that it might.

They test the information, not just the conclusions

Independent directors look behind the numbers. They ask how a forecast was built, compare it with previous forecasts, and check whether the KPIs in the board pack are the ones that matter. They want to know where the information came from and who prepared it. Our guide to what good board papers look like sets out what boards should expect.

They disagree in the room and minute it

Disagreement that only happens in corridors does not count. On an independent board, concerns are raised at the meeting, discussed properly and, where they remain unresolved, recorded in the minutes. That record protects individual directors and signals to management that the board’s views are real. Our guide to being the voice of reason covers how to do this well.

They resist groupthink

A board of individually independent directors can still think as one if everyone shares the same background, the same assumptions and the same reluctance to break consensus. Independent boards deliberately bring in different perspectives and make it normal for someone to argue the other side. See our guide to avoiding groupthink when selecting NEDs.

The Conditions That Make Independence Possible

Behaviour depends on conditions. Directors cannot challenge what they cannot see, and they will not challenge if the chair makes it clear that challenge is unwelcome. These are the practical conditions that allow independence of mind to function.

Access to information beyond the board pack

NEDs who rely solely on what management chooses to put in the board pack are, in effect, dependent on management for their view of the business. Independent boards ensure NEDs can speak to the CFO, the heads of risk, compliance and internal audit, and the external auditor without the CEO present. They visit sites, meet customers and talk to people below executive level. They can take independent professional advice at the company’s expense where needed.

Time without the executives

The Code expects the chair to hold meetings with the non-executive directors without the executives present. These sessions give NEDs space to compare impressions, raise concerns about management and agree how to handle difficult issues before they reach the full board. Boards that skip them, or treat them as a formality, lose one of the simplest safeguards of independent thinking.

A chair who wants challenge

The chair sets the tone. A chair who is too close to the CEO, who dominates discussion or who closes down dissent will produce a deferential board however carefully its members were chosen. An independent board needs a chair who invites challenge, gives every director airtime, protects the director who raises the awkward point and makes sure decisions are genuinely open until the board has discussed them. The senior independent director provides a further check, including on the chair.

Enough independent directors to carry weight

A single independent NED on a board of founders, executives and investor directors can be isolated, however capable they are. Independence is easier to exercise when there are enough independent voices to support each other and to make challenge normal rather than personal. Our guide to board structure, composition and independence covers the balance. For the personal side of being the lone independent voice, see the loneliness of independent NEDs.

What Erodes Independence Over Time

Independence is rarely lost in a single moment. It wears away gradually, often without the director noticing. Boards should watch for these pressures.

  • Tenure. Long service brings knowledge, but it also brings familiarity with management, attachment to past decisions and a tendency to see the business the way the executives do. The Code treats service beyond nine years as a factor likely to affect independence. Many directors become less independent well before that point. Planned rotation helps; see our guide to planning NED rotation without losing continuity.
  • Personal relationships. Friendships with executives, shared social circles and the natural loyalty that builds over years of working together can all make challenge harder. None of these is improper, but directors should be honest with themselves about their effect.
  • Remuneration and dependence. A director whose NED fee is a large share of their income, or who hopes to be reappointed, may be less willing to take an unpopular stand. Fees that include share options or performance-related pay create similar pressure, which is why the Code expects NED pay to avoid them.
  • Shareholdings. Holding shares can align a NED with shareholders, but a large holding, or one acquired on special terms, can tie the director’s interests too closely to particular outcomes. Our guide to NEDs holding company shares covers the balance.
  • Additional work for the company. Consulting fees, advisory work or other paid roles alongside the board seat create a commercial relationship that sits uneasily with independence. Our article on hybrid board roles discusses when these arrangements work.
  • Conflicts that are not managed. Undeclared or poorly managed conflicts undermine both the director’s independence and the board’s credibility. See our guide to handling conflicts of interest.

How to Assess Independence in Practice

Because independence of mind cannot be read from a CV, boards need to look for evidence in how the board actually works. The annual board evaluation is the natural place to do it.

Useful questions for an evaluation include:

  • How often in the past year has the board rejected, deferred or materially changed a management proposal, and why?
  • Do NEDs feel able to raise concerns at meetings, and are those concerns followed through?
  • Does the board receive information that management would not have chosen to share, from internal audit, risk, the external auditor or direct contact with the business?
  • How regularly do the NEDs meet without the executives, and do those meetings lead to anything?
  • Does any director rely on the company for a significant share of their income, or have relationships with executives that could affect their judgement?
  • Are there directors whose tenure, history or relationships mean the board should reconsider whether they are independent?

Interviews conducted by someone outside the board, whether the senior independent director, the company secretary or an external facilitator, often reveal more than questionnaires. Directors are more candid about deference and dominant personalities when they are confident their comments will be handled carefully. Our guides to running a board evaluation and independent board evaluations explain the options.

Independence on Different Kinds of Board

Board How independence is usually judged
Listed company Against the UK Corporate Governance Code tests, with the board explaining any exception
Private equity-backed Investor directors are not independent; independent directors are free of links to the investor and management
Family business Independent of the family and of any family member’s business interests
Charity Trustees are normally unpaid, and conflicts with connected people and organisations are managed carefully
FCA-regulated firm Independence of chairs and committee chairs matters to the regulator’s view of the board

Jodie says

Independence shows up in references

Formal tests tell you little about how a director behaves. We ask referees for an example of the candidate disagreeing with a chair, a chief executive or a major shareholder.

When no referee can think of one, it is worth asking why.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

What Individual NEDs Can Do

Independence is partly a board-level quality and partly a personal discipline. Individual directors can protect their own independence by:

  • preparing thoroughly, so that challenge is grounded in evidence rather than instinct;
  • building their own sources of information about the business, within proper channels;
  • being honest with themselves about relationships, financial dependence and the effect of long service;
  • raising concerns early, at the meeting, and asking for them to be minuted if they are not resolved;
  • keeping enough distance from executives to be able to disagree with them; and
  • knowing when the time has come to step down because they can no longer bring a fresh perspective.

Our article on why independence matters more than ever explains why investors, regulators and lenders are paying closer attention to how independent boards really are.

Independence Beyond Listed Companies

The formal tests come from the Code, which applies to listed companies, but the practical questions apply everywhere. On a private equity board, the independent chair and NEDs are often the only directors without a financial stake in a particular outcome, and their value depends on being seen to exercise genuine judgement. In a family business, an independent NED may be the only person able to challenge the family’s assumptions. In a regulated firm, the regulator will look at whether independent directors genuinely oversee management. Our guide to why UK companies need independent NEDs covers the case by company type.

When we recruit independent directors through our independent non-executive director recruitment service, we assess the formal position, but we spend more time on the evidence of independent judgement: how candidates have handled disagreement, what they have challenged, and how they have behaved when the board was under pressure.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a board be independent on paper but not in practice?
Yes. A board can meet every formal test and still defer to management if directors lack information, the chair discourages challenge or the board culture prizes consensus. The formal tests identify conditions for independence; they do not guarantee it.

Can a non-independent director show independence of mind?
Yes. Every director has a legal duty to exercise independent judgement, and many investor directors and former executives challenge management well. Their classification reflects circumstances that could affect their objectivity, not a finding that they lack it.

What is the single most important condition for an independent board?
The chair. A chair who wants challenge, gives every director a voice and keeps decisions open until the board has debated them makes independence possible. A chair who is too close to the CEO or dominates discussion makes it very hard.

How long can a NED serve before independence is at risk?
The Code treats service beyond nine years as a factor likely to affect independence. In practice, directors and boards should consider the question well before that point, because familiarity builds gradually.

How should a board test its own independence?
Use the annual evaluation to look for evidence: how often the board has changed or rejected proposals, whether NEDs receive information management would not have chosen to share, how executive-free sessions work and whether any director’s relationships or circumstances have changed.

Do private companies need to worry about board independence?
The Code does not apply to them, but the practical value of independent judgement does. Investors, lenders and regulators increasingly look at whether a private company’s board can genuinely challenge management.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Strengthening Your Board’s Independence?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about appointing independent non-executive directors who will bring genuine challenge to your board. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.