What Insurance Do Non-Executive Directors Need?

What insurance a non-executive director needs — why D&O cover is the one that matters, how Side A/B/C works, and the gaps every NED should check

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Private Equity and Venture-Backed Businesses Non-Executive Recruitment

What Insurance Do Non-Executive Directors Need?

What Insurance Do Non-Executive Directors Need?

A non-executive director is a director in the full legal sense. You owe the company the same statutory duties as any executive director, and you can be held personally responsible if those duties are breached. Shareholders can bring claims, a liquidator can pursue directors after an insolvency, and regulators can investigate individuals as well as companies. That personal exposure is why insurance matters.

The good news is that the answer to “what insurance does a NED need?” is more focused than a long list of policy types suggests. For most non-executive directors, one policy does the essential work, and it is arranged and paid for by the company. The real task is checking that the company’s cover is adequate, alongside the indemnity the company gives you. This guide explains how that works and what to check. It is general information, not insurance or legal advice; for a specific appointment, speak to the company’s broker or your own adviser.

Why NEDs Need Protection at All

It is sometimes assumed that because non-executives are part-time and do not run the business, they carry less legal risk. That is not how UK company law works. Under the Companies Act 2006 every director owes the same general duties, including the duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence. The standard is judged both against what can reasonably be expected of anyone in the role and against your own knowledge and experience, so an experienced finance professional on the audit committee will be held to a higher standard on financial matters. Our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director sets these out.

Claims and investigations involving directors can arise from several directions:

  • shareholders alleging a breach of duty or misleading statements;
  • a liquidator or administrator pursuing directors after an insolvency, for example for wrongful trading;
  • regulators investigating a firm and the individuals on its board, particularly in FCA-regulated businesses;
  • employees, customers, suppliers or other third parties bringing claims that name the directors personally;
  • health and safety, environmental or data protection investigations.

Most of these never reach a judgment against a director, but defending them can be expensive and slow. The main value of insurance for a NED is often the payment of legal defence costs while a matter is investigated or defended. Our articles on whether NEDs are personally liable for debts and why NEDs are increasingly targeted by regulators explain the background.

D&O Insurance: The Policy That Matters

Directors’ and officers’ liability insurance covers directors and officers for claims made against them for alleged wrongful acts in their capacity as directors, such as breach of duty, negligence, misstatement or breach of trust. It typically pays defence costs, and may pay settlements and damages where the law allows.

The company buys the policy for its directors and officers. Section 233 of the Companies Act 2006 expressly allows a company to purchase and maintain insurance for its directors against liability arising from negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust (s233). A NED should not normally need to buy their own policy, and a company that carries no D&O insurance at all is itself a warning sign about how seriously it takes governance.

How Side A, B and C cover works

D&O policies are usually described in three parts, or “sides”:

  • Side A protects the individual director directly where the company does not or cannot indemnify them, for example because the law prevents it, the company refuses, or the company is insolvent. For a NED this is the most important part of the policy, because it is the protection that still works when the company cannot help.
  • Side B reimburses the company where it has indemnified a director. It protects the company’s balance sheet rather than the individual.
  • Side C, often called entity cover, protects the company itself against certain claims, most commonly securities claims for listed companies. It can be useful to the company but it shares the policy limit with the directors.

The interaction between these sides matters. If a policy has a single limit shared across Sides A, B and C, a large claim against the company could erode the cover available to the individual directors. That is why many larger companies buy additional Side A-only cover dedicated to the directors.

What D&O insurance commonly excludes

Wordings vary between insurers and policies, so the actual policy needs to be read, but common exclusions include:

  • deliberate fraud, dishonesty or criminal acts, usually once established by a final judgment or admission;
  • gaining a profit or advantage to which the director was not legally entitled;
  • fines and penalties that cannot lawfully be insured;
  • claims already known about, or arising from circumstances known before the policy started;
  • bodily injury and property damage, which belong under other liability policies;
  • in some policies, claims brought by a major shareholder or by one insured against another.

Note that defence costs are often paid while allegations of dishonesty are defended, with exclusions applying only if the conduct is later proved. How a particular policy handles this is worth checking.

The Deed of Indemnity: The Other Half of the Protection

Insurance is one layer of protection. The other is an indemnity from the company itself, usually documented in the articles of association and in a separate deed of indemnity given to each director.

The Companies Act limits what a company can do here. Section 232 makes void any provision that exempts a director from liability for negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust in relation to the company, or that indemnifies them against that liability, except as the Act permits. The main permitted routes are:

  • Insurance under section 233, as above.
  • A qualifying third party indemnity provision under section 234. This lets the company indemnify a director against liability to people other than the company or an associated company. It cannot cover fines imposed in criminal proceedings, regulatory penalties, the costs of defending criminal proceedings in which the director is convicted, or the costs of defending civil proceedings brought by the company in which judgment is given against the director.
  • Funding defence costs as they are incurred, under section 205, on terms that the money is repaid if the director is convicted or judgment is given against them.

Qualifying indemnity provisions must be disclosed in the directors’ report under section 236, which is a useful way to check what a company already provides.

The practical point for a NED is that an indemnity is only as good as the company’s ability to pay. If the company becomes insolvent, the indemnity may be worth little, and that is precisely where Side A D&O cover matters. The two protections work together: the indemnity responds first in normal times, and the insurance backs it up, especially when the company cannot.

What a NED Should Check Before Accepting

Before you accept a board seat, it is entirely reasonable to ask for confirmation of the insurance and indemnity position. A well-run board will expect the question. The points worth checking are:

  1. That D&O cover exists and that you will be an insured person from your start date.
  2. The limit of indemnity, and whether it is shared across Sides A, B and C. Ask whether there is any dedicated Side A cover.
  3. Who else shares the limit, such as subsidiaries or other group companies, and whether that is adequate for the size and risk of the business.
  4. Run-off cover: claims can be made years after a director leaves. Check that former directors remain covered, and what happens if the company is sold or enters insolvency. A change of control often converts the policy into run-off, so it is worth asking how long that run-off lasts.
  5. Regulatory investigation cover, particularly in FCA-regulated firms, including the costs of attending interviews and responding to information requests.
  6. The deed of indemnity: ask for a copy and check it covers you to the extent the law allows, including defence costs funding.
  7. Notification obligations: understand how and when circumstances must be notified to insurers, because late notification can affect cover.

These points sit alongside the wider letter of appointment terms covered in our guide to negotiating board role terms. For first-time non-executives, our article on how to negotiate your first NED contract explains how to raise them without damaging the relationship.

Common D&O Policy Exclusions

Exclusion What it usually means
Fraud and dishonesty Not covered once established by a court or admission; defence costs are often paid until then
Prior or known claims Matters known before the policy started are excluded
Fines and penalties Many fines cannot be insured by law
Insured versus insured Claims by the company or other directors may be excluded, with carve-backs for some situations
Bodily injury and property damage Usually covered by other policies instead
Major shareholder claims Some policies exclude claims by large shareholders

Wording varies widely between insurers, so ask to see the policy itself or a broker’s summary rather than relying on a general description.

Jodie says

Ask for the summary before the offer

We encourage candidates to ask for the D&O summary before they accept. Boards that are well run will share it readily, and it often answers the run-off cover question at the same time.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Do NEDs Ever Need Their Own Insurance?

Usually not, but there are situations where personal cover is worth considering.

Personal D&O or top-up cover

Some experienced portfolio non-executives buy personal D&O cover, sometimes called an “outside directorship” or personal top-up policy. It can sit above the company’s cover and respond where the company’s limit has been exhausted or the company’s policy does not respond. It can be useful where you hold several board roles, sit on boards in higher-risk sectors, or are concerned about the adequacy of a particular company’s cover. Our guide to balancing multiple NED roles covers portfolio considerations more broadly.

Professional indemnity for advisory work

D&O insurance covers you in your capacity as a director. If you also provide consultancy or advisory services to the company, or to others, through your own business, that activity is not directorship and may need professional indemnity insurance. The same applies if you sit on an advisory board rather than the statutory board. Our article on advisory boards vs boards of directors explains why the distinction matters, including the risk of being treated as a shadow director.

Charity trustees

Charities can often buy trustee indemnity insurance, subject to their governing document and charity law. If you are considering a trustee role, check what cover the charity holds. Our guide to the difference between a trustee and a NED explains how the legal position differs.

Insurance in Higher-Risk Situations

Some appointments deserve extra care on insurance:

  • Companies in financial difficulty or turnaround. Insolvency-related claims are a common source of D&O claims, and the company’s indemnity may not be worth much if it fails. Run-off and Side A cover are central. Our page on turnaround and restructuring NEDs covers these roles.
  • FCA-regulated firms. Senior managers and NEDs can face regulatory investigation personally. Our hub on FCA-regulated board governance explains the regime.
  • Companies preparing for a sale or listing. Transactions bring prospectus and warranty risks, and a change of control can trigger run-off.
  • Cyber and data incidents. Boards increasingly face scrutiny after serious incidents. Check how the D&O policy and any separate cyber policy interact. Our guide to the NED’s role in a cyber crisis covers board responsibilities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a non-executive director need their own insurance?
Usually not. The company normally arranges and pays for directors’ and officers’ (D&O) liability insurance that covers all its directors. A NED’s main task is checking that the company’s cover and indemnity are adequate, though some portfolio NEDs choose to buy personal top-up cover.

What is Side A D&O cover?
Side A protects individual directors directly where the company cannot or will not indemnify them, for example if it is insolvent. It is the part of a D&O policy that matters most to a non-executive director.

Can a company indemnify its directors against everything?
No. The Companies Act 2006 limits company indemnities. A qualifying third party indemnity cannot cover criminal fines, regulatory penalties, or the costs of criminal proceedings where the director is convicted or of civil proceedings brought by the company that the director loses.

Am I still covered after I leave the board?
Claims can be made long after a director leaves, so check that former directors remain covered under the company’s policy, and what run-off cover applies if the company is sold or becomes insolvent.

Does D&O insurance cover regulatory investigations?
Many policies include some cover for investigation costs, but the scope varies and regulatory fines are generally not insurable. This is particularly important to check in FCA-regulated firms.

Is it acceptable to ask about insurance before accepting a role?
Yes. Any well-run board expects an incoming director to ask for confirmation of the D&O cover and a copy of the deed of indemnity. It shows you understand the responsibilities of the role.

Related Guides and Services

Understanding the risks and protections of board roles.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Discussing a Board Appointment?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about a non-executive role or appointment. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.