How to Negotiate Your First Non-Executive Director Contract

A first NED appointment? How to actually conduct the negotiation — the mindset, the preparation, raising terms well, and the mistakes first-timers make.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Private Equity NED Search Process

How to Negotiate Your First Non-Executive Director Contract

How to Negotiate Your First Non-Executive Director Contract

Being offered your first board seat is a milestone. After months of networking, interviews and conversations with chairs, the natural instinct is to say yes quickly and sort out the detail later. That instinct is understandable, but the period between the offer and your acceptance is the one point at which you can shape the terms of the role, and how you handle it tells the chair a good deal about how you will behave in the boardroom.

This guide is about the first-time NED’s position in that conversation. It covers what kind of document you are actually signing, which terms are normally set by the company and which are genuinely open, how much leverage a first-timer has, and how to raise the points that matter without coming across as difficult. It deliberately does not repeat the full list of terms to check; that checklist is in our companion guide, negotiating board role terms: what NEDs should ask. Read the two together.

First, Understand What You Are Signing

Most first-time non-executives expect a contract of employment. In practice, a non-executive director is usually appointed by a letter of appointment, not a service contract. The difference matters, because it shapes what you can sensibly negotiate.

An executive director normally has a service contract: an employment relationship with salary, benefits, notice periods, restrictive covenants and the protections of employment law. A non-executive director holds an office. Your appointment is made by the board or the shareholders under the company’s articles of association, and the letter of appointment records the terms on which you hold that office: the expected time commitment, the fee, the term, committee roles, expenses, confidentiality, insurance and the circumstances in which the appointment ends.

Three consequences follow for a first-timer:

  • The letter sits beneath the law and the articles. It cannot reduce the duties you owe as a director under the Companies Act 2006, and it cannot override the articles on how directors are appointed and removed. Our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director explains what those duties are.
  • You are rarely an employee. NEDs do not usually have employment rights, so there is little point negotiating for things like enhanced notice pay or severance. Shareholders can normally remove a director, and good practice is that NEDs are not compensated for loss of office.
  • Fees are still taxed as employment income. Even though you are an office-holder rather than an employee, HMRC treats director’s fees as earnings that go through payroll. Our article on whether non-executive directors pay National Insurance covers this, and it affects how you should think about the fee conversation.

Long fixed-term service contracts for directors are also restricted by statute: under section 188 of the Companies Act 2006, a director’s guaranteed term of more than two years needs shareholder approval. This is one reason NED letters of appointment are usually set out as a defined term, often three years, that can be ended by either side on notice.

What Is Usually Fixed, and What Is Genuinely Open

The single most useful thing a first-time NED can do is understand which terms are set by the company and which are open to discussion. Pushing on fixed terms wastes goodwill. Accepting open terms without thought can leave you with a role that does not work.

Terms that are usually fixed

For most appointments, particularly at larger or listed companies, the following are normally set by the board or by policy and are not individually negotiated:

  • The base fee. Listed companies set NED fees within a policy approved by shareholders, and most well-run private boards have a standard fee for every NED. A first-timer is very unlikely to move the base fee. If you want to understand whether it is fair, our NED salary guide and our page on how boards benchmark NED fees explain how fees are set.
  • Committee and chair supplements. These normally follow a published scale rather than individual negotiation.
  • The standard confidentiality, conflicts and share-dealing provisions. These reflect legal and regulatory obligations and apply to every director.
  • Re-election arrangements. Where a company follows the UK Corporate Governance Code, directors stand for annual re-election, and that is not something an individual director can change.

Terms that are genuinely open

Other points are normally open to sensible discussion, and they are often where a first-time NED should focus:

  • The realistic time commitment. The letter usually states an expected number of days. What matters is whether that figure is honest. Ask what the existing NEDs actually spend, particularly around year end, budget season and any transaction. Our guide to how much time a NED really commits each month gives a sense of what to expect.
  • Committee roles. Whether you join the audit, remuneration or nomination committee, and when, is usually a board decision, but the chair will normally discuss it with you. A first-timer may reasonably prefer to join a committee for a year before chairing one.
  • Start date and induction. You can and should ask what induction the company will provide, and agree a start date that lets you read in properly.
  • Access to information and people. Agreeing upfront that you will have access to management, the auditors and independent advice where needed is reasonable and rarely resisted.
  • Insurance and indemnity. The existence and adequacy of D&O insurance and a deed of indemnity are legitimate points to confirm before you sign. Our guide to what insurance non-executive directors need explains what to check.
  • Equity, in private companies only. In some private and PE-backed businesses there may be a conversation about co-investment or growth shares. In listed companies the Code position is that NEDs should not receive share options, which our guide to NED share options explains.

How Much Leverage Does a First-Time NED Really Have?

Honestly, not a great deal on money, and quite a lot on substance.

On fees and headline terms, a first-time non-executive is usually one of several credible candidates for the seat, and the board has a standard package. Trying to negotiate the base fee is more likely to raise questions than to change the number. That is not a reason to be passive, but it is a reason to choose your points carefully.

On substance, you have more leverage than you might think. The board has invested time in finding you and wants the appointment to work. A chair will almost always welcome questions about time, committee roles, induction, information flow and liability protection, because those questions show that you are taking the role seriously. Raising them well is often seen as an early sign of the judgement you are being appointed for.

Your leverage also depends on the type of board:

  • Listed companies have the least flexibility on terms. Fees and policies are set and disclosed, and the letter of appointment is usually a standard document.
  • Private equity-backed companies often have more flexibility, particularly on equity and time commitment, but the investor will have its own expectations. Our guide to the role of a PE NED covers how these boards work.
  • Private and family companies may have no standard letter at all. Here the first-time NED may need to suggest the terms that should be written down, which is an opportunity as well as a responsibility.
  • Charities are different again: trustees are usually unpaid, so the conversation centres on time, expectations and protection. Our article on the difference between a trustee and a NED explains why.

How to Raise Points Without Damaging the Relationship

The way you raise terms matters as much as which terms you raise. A few principles help.

Raise everything before you accept

Settle the terms during the offer stage, not after you have said yes. Once you have accepted, any later request looks like second thoughts. Ask for the draft letter of appointment, read it properly, and raise your points in one considered conversation rather than a series of emails.

Prioritise

Decide in advance which two or three points genuinely matter to you. For most first-time NEDs these are the realistic time commitment, the insurance and indemnity position, and committee roles. Raising ten minor points signals that you may be hard work in the boardroom.

Frame questions around doing the job well

“I want to make sure I can give this the time it needs, so could you tell me what the other NEDs spend around year end?” lands very differently from “I need to know exactly how many days this will take.” The first shows that you are thinking about the role. The second sounds like a negotiation over effort.

Talk to the chair, not just the company secretary

Administrative points can go to the company secretary or HR, but substantive questions about the role belong with the chair. It is also the first real conversation you will have with the person you will work most closely with, so treat it as such.

Get the important points in writing

If the chair agrees something that matters, such as a committee role starting after your first year, or access to an independent adviser, ask for it to be reflected in the letter of appointment or confirmed in writing. Memories differ, and chairs change.

Raising Points Without Damaging the Relationship

Point A constructive way to raise it
The time commitment “Could you tell me how many days the last director gave in their final year?”
D&O cover “Could I see a summary of the D&O policy, including run-off cover?”
The fee “How does the fee compare with similar boards, and when is it reviewed?”
Committee roles “Which committees would I join, and what do they meet on?”
Notice “What notice would each side give if the role ended?”

Jodie says

Good boards welcome sensible questions

First-time NEDs often worry that asking about terms will look demanding. In our experience, chairs respect candidates who ask sensible questions about time, insurance and the role. It shows they are taking it seriously.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Getting Advice

Most first-time NEDs do not need a lawyer to review a standard letter of appointment from a well-run company, but there are situations where advice is sensible:

  • the company is in financial difficulty, in a turnaround, or close to a transaction;
  • the role is in an FCA-regulated firm and carries a Senior Management Function, where your personal regulatory responsibilities need to be clear (our guide to appointing a NED for an FCA-regulated firm explains the approval process);
  • you are being offered equity, co-investment or any arrangement that affects your tax position;
  • there is no D&O insurance, or the indemnity looks unusually narrow;
  • the letter contains restrictions on your other appointments that seem wider than the role justifies.

Advice does not have to be adversarial. Asking a lawyer or accountant to check a few points and then raising them yourself with the chair keeps the relationship direct and constructive.

Red Lines: When Not to Accept

Part of negotiating well is being genuinely prepared to walk away. For a first-time non-executive, a few issues should give real pause:

  • No D&O insurance, or a refusal to confirm the cover, particularly in a business with any financial strain. Our article on whether non-executive directors are personally liable for debts explains the exposure.
  • A refusal to share information you need to assess the company before joining, such as recent board papers, management accounts or audit findings.
  • A time commitment that does not fit with your executive role or other commitments, especially where your employer has not yet consented.
  • Pressure to accept quickly without proper due diligence, or terms that would compromise your independence.
  • A role that is really executive, where you are expected to run part of the business while being described as a non-executive.

Our guide on when a NED should walk away from a board appointment covers these warning signs in more detail. Turning down a first role feels counter-intuitive, but a bad first appointment can be far more damaging to a board career than waiting for the right one.

A Simple Sequence for First-Time NEDs

  1. Before the offer: do your due diligence on the company and decide whether the role is right for you. Our article on how to decide if a NED role is right for you helps.
  2. At the offer: thank the chair, express your interest and ask for the draft letter of appointment and supporting documents.
  3. Review: check the letter against the full list in our board terms guide, and decide on your two or three priorities.
  4. Discuss: raise your points with the chair in a single conversation, framed around doing the job well.
  5. Confirm: make sure what was agreed is reflected in writing before you sign.
  6. Accept and prepare: agree your induction and start reading in. Our guide to preparing for your first board pack is a good next step.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do non-executive directors get an employment contract?
Usually not. A NED is normally appointed by a letter of appointment that records the terms of the office, rather than a service contract of employment. Executive directors have service contracts; non-executive directors generally do not.

Can a first-time NED negotiate the fee?
Rarely. Most boards have a standard fee for all NEDs, and listed companies set fees within a shareholder-approved policy. A first-timer will usually gain more by focusing on time commitment, committee roles and insurance than on the base fee.

Is it acceptable to ask about D&O insurance before accepting?
Yes. Any well-run board expects an incoming director to confirm the D&O insurance and indemnity position. Asking is a sign that you understand the role, not that you expect something to go wrong.

Should I get legal advice on my letter of appointment?
For a standard letter from a well-run company, many first-time NEDs do not. It is sensible where the company is in difficulty, the role is in a regulated firm, equity is involved or the insurance and indemnity terms look unusual.

How long is a typical first NED term?
Terms of three years are common, renewable by agreement, and in companies following the UK Corporate Governance Code directors stand for annual re-election. Our article on typical NED term lengths covers this.

What if the company has no standard letter of appointment?
That is common in smaller private and family businesses. In that case, suggest the points that should be written down, using a checklist such as our board terms guide, and agree them with the chair before you start.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Considering Your First Board Role?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about non-executive opportunities. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.