When Boards Should Commission an Independent Review

When boards should commission an independent review — the triennial board effectiveness review, governance failures, disputes and regulatory triggers, explained.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
How do I develop a strategic mindset?

When Boards Should Commission an Independent Review

When Boards Should Commission an Independent Review

Most of what a board does, it does for itself. It reviews performance, challenges management and takes decisions on the information in front of it. But there are moments when the board’s own view is not enough. Either the board is too close to the issue, or the people it would normally rely on are part of the problem, or outsiders such as investors, regulators or employees need to see that the matter has been examined by someone without a stake in the answer.

Knowing when those moments have arrived, and acting on them promptly, is a mark of a well-governed board. A board that never reaches for independent scrutiny is often the one that most needs it. This guide sets out the main triggers for an independent review, the different kinds of review available, how to scope and oversee one, and the role non-executive directors should play.

Why Independence Matters

An independent review is valuable for two reasons. The first is quality. A reviewer from outside the organisation brings fresh eyes, specialist skills and no loyalty to the people or decisions under examination. They are more likely to find what is really going on.

The second is credibility. A conclusion reached by the people responsible for a problem is rarely believed, however sound it is. A conclusion reached by a properly independent reviewer, under clear terms of reference, carries weight with shareholders, auditors, regulators, employees and the press. Sometimes the board already knows the answer and needs independent confirmation to act on it. Our article on why independence matters more than ever explains the wider principle.

Trigger 1: Routine Review of the Board’s Own Effectiveness

The most common and least dramatic reason to commission an independent review is simply good governance. Provision 21 of the 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code says there should be a formal and rigorous annual review of the performance of the board, its committees, the chair and individual directors. It adds that the chair should commission a regular externally facilitated board performance review, and that in FTSE 350 companies this should happen at least every three years. The external reviewer should be named in the annual report, along with any other connection it has with the company or its directors.

An external board performance review looks at how the board works: its composition and skills, the quality of discussion and challenge, the effectiveness of the chair, how the committees function, the quality of board papers and the dynamics of the group. Companies outside the FTSE 350, private companies and charities are not bound by that timetable, but many find a periodic external review valuable, particularly after a change of chair or a period of rapid growth.

Our guides to independent board evaluations and how board effectiveness reviews work cover this routine case in detail. The rest of this article focuses on the less predictable triggers.

Trigger 2: Whistleblowing and Allegations of Wrongdoing

Provision 6 of the Code says there should be a means for the workforce to raise concerns in confidence and, if they wish, anonymously. It also says the board should routinely review these arrangements and the reports arising from them, and should ensure that arrangements are in place for the proportionate and independent investigation of such matters and for follow-up action.

That last point is important. Not every whistleblowing report needs an external investigator. Many can be investigated properly by internal audit, compliance or HR. But an independent review becomes necessary when:

  • the allegation concerns a senior executive, a director or someone in the chain of people who would normally investigate it;
  • the allegation, if true, could have a material effect on the financial statements, regulatory standing or reputation of the company;
  • there are multiple reports pointing to the same issue, suggesting something systemic;
  • the whistleblower has already raised the concern internally and believes it was not taken seriously.

In regulated financial services firms, the FCA has specific whistleblowing rules, including the role of the whistleblowers’ champion, who is usually a non-executive director. Our FCA-regulated board governance hub covers that role.

Trigger 3: A Serious Incident, Loss or Failed Project

When something significant goes wrong, such as a major fraud, a large unexpected loss, a cyber attack, a failed acquisition or a technology programme that runs far over budget, the board needs to understand what happened, why and whether it could happen again. If the executive team was responsible for the area in question, asking it to investigate itself puts both the executives and the board in an uncomfortable position.

An independent lessons-learned or root-cause review gives the board a clear account it can rely on. For cyber incidents in particular, our article on the NED’s role in cyber crisis response explains why a post-incident review should be independent of the team that handled the response.

Where the incident involves possible financial misstatement or fraud, the review may need forensic accounting skills, and the audit committee should usually lead the board’s oversight. Our article on what an audit committee actually does sets out its role in this area.

Trigger 4: Concerns About Culture or Conduct

Culture problems rarely announce themselves. They show up as a cluster of signals: high staff turnover in one part of the business, grievance or tribunal claims, poor engagement survey results, customer complaints, or reports of bullying or harassment. Principle B of the Code asks the board to satisfy itself that the company’s purpose, values, strategy and culture are aligned, and Provision 2 asks it to assess and monitor culture. Where the board is not satisfied that policy, practices or behaviour across the business are aligned with the company’s purpose, values and strategy, it should seek assurance that management has taken corrective action.

When the signals point to a problem the board cannot assess from management information alone, an independent culture review can help. These typically combine interviews, focus groups, surveys and analysis of data such as complaints and exits. The reviewer’s independence makes it more likely that staff will speak openly. Our articles on how NEDs shape organisational culture and the NED’s role in promoting an ethical culture cover the board’s wider responsibilities.

Trigger 5: Boardroom Disputes and Conflicts of Interest

Sometimes the problem is in the boardroom itself. A breakdown in the relationship between the chair and chief executive, a dispute between shareholder-appointed directors, or a serious conflict of interest involving a director can paralyse a board. Provision 7 of the Code asks the board to identify and manage conflicts of interest and ensure that third-party influence does not override independent judgement.

Where the board cannot resolve such a situation internally, an independent review, often commissioned by the senior independent director, can establish the facts and recommend a way forward. Our guide to the senior independent director explains why the SID often leads in these situations, and our article on CEO versus chairman covers the power dynamics involved.

Trigger 6: When a Regulator Expects or Requires a Review

In regulated sectors, the decision may not be entirely the board’s. In financial services, section 166 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 allows the FCA or PRA to require a report from a skilled person on matters relating to a regulated firm. The regulator may appoint the skilled person directly or approve a skilled person nominated by the firm. The firm pays the costs, and the skilled person’s reports go to the regulator. The FCA’s skilled person reviews page sets out how the regime works.

A skilled person review is a significant event for a board. It often follows supervisory concerns about systems and controls, conduct, financial crime or client money. Boards that spot a problem early and commission their own independent review, before the regulator does, are often better placed: they show they understand the issue and are taking it seriously. Our sister firm FD Capital has published a detailed guide to section 166 reviews.

Other regulators, including the Charity Commission, Ofsted, the Care Quality Commission and sector regulators in water, energy and housing, may also expect boards to commission independent reviews after serious failures.

Trigger 7: Ahead of a Major Transaction or Change

Before a sale, listing, major acquisition or change of control, a board may commission an independent review of governance, controls or specific risks to identify problems before investors or buyers do. This is less about investigating wrongdoing and more about readiness. Private equity investors in particular often expect a portfolio company to fix governance gaps before an exit. Our article on how private equity governance works explains why.

Types of Independent Review at a Glance

Type Usually commissioned by Typical trigger
External board evaluation The chair Routine review of board effectiveness
Investigation The board or a committee of independent directors Whistleblowing, allegations or a serious incident
Forensic accounting review The audit committee Suspected fraud or accounting irregularities
Culture review The board or the people committee Concerns about behaviour, conduct or wellbeing
Skilled person review Required by the FCA under section 166 of FSMA Regulatory concerns in an FCA-regulated firm

Jodie says

Reviews often reveal a gap on the board

A good number of the board searches we are asked to run follow an independent review. The review identifies what was missing, such as audit experience or a stronger independent chair, and the board acts on it.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Choosing the Right Kind of Review

“Independent review” covers several quite different exercises. Choosing the wrong one wastes money and can leave the real question unanswered.

Board performance review. Looks at how the board and its committees work. Forward-looking, developmental and usually carried out by a governance specialist.

Investigation. Establishes the facts about a specific allegation or incident. Often carried out by lawyers, sometimes with forensic accountants, and may lead to disciplinary action, regulatory reporting or legal proceedings.

Forensic review. A specialist financial investigation into possible fraud, misstatement or misappropriation, usually commissioned through the audit committee.

Lessons-learned or root-cause review. Looks at why something went wrong and what needs to change, without necessarily attributing individual blame.

Culture review. Assesses behaviours, values and working practices across the organisation or in a particular area.

Skilled person review. A regulatory review under section 166 FSMA, with the scope set by the regulator.

Scoping, Privilege and Oversight

Once the board has decided a review is needed, how it is set up matters as much as who carries it out.

Agree clear terms of reference

The terms of reference should state the question the review is to answer, its scope and any limits, the period covered, who the reviewer reports to, what access they will have to people, documents and systems, and the expected timetable. Vague terms of reference produce vague reports.

Decide who oversees it

The review should report to people who are not implicated in the matter under review. That usually means a committee of independent non-executive directors, the audit committee for financial matters, or a special committee set up for the purpose. Where the chair or chief executive is involved, the senior independent director often leads.

Think about legal privilege early

Where a review may lead to litigation, regulatory action or disciplinary proceedings, it is worth taking legal advice before it starts. Whether the review’s work and report can be protected by legal privilege can depend on how it is commissioned and who carries it out. This is a technical area, and boards should not assume privilege applies without advice.

Protect the people involved

Whistleblowers must be protected from retaliation, and people under investigation are entitled to fair treatment. Data protection law also applies to the personal information a review collects. Good reviewers will build these protections into their process.

Act on the findings

A review that is commissioned and then ignored is worse than no review at all. The board should agree an action plan in response, assign owners and deadlines, and track progress. Provision 22 of the Code makes the same point for board performance reviews: the chair should act on the results.

The Role of Non-Executive Directors

Non-executive directors are central to all of this. They are often the first to sense that something needs independent examination, because they see the business from a distance and receive information from several directions. They should be willing to press for a review even when executives resist, and they usually lead the oversight once one is under way.

That requires independence of mind, confidence and relevant experience. If your board lacks directors with investigation, audit or regulatory experience, it may be worth adding one. NED Capital recruits independent non-executive directors, audit committee chairs and senior independent directors for boards that need to strengthen their oversight.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should a board have an external review of its effectiveness?
Under the 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code, FTSE 350 companies should have an externally facilitated board performance review at least every three years, alongside an annual internal review. Other companies can choose their own timetable, but a periodic external review is good practice.

Who should commission an independent investigation into a senior executive?
The board, acting through independent non-executive directors who are not involved in the matter. This is often the audit committee, a special committee or the senior independent director. The executive under investigation should play no part in commissioning or overseeing it.

What is a section 166 skilled person review?
It is a review the FCA or PRA can require under section 166 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000. The regulator may appoint the skilled person or approve one nominated by the firm. The firm pays, and the reports go to the regulator.

Is an independent review legally privileged?
Not automatically. Whether privilege applies depends on how the review is set up and its purpose. If litigation or regulatory action is possible, take legal advice before the review starts.

Does every whistleblowing report need an external investigator?
No. The Code asks for proportionate and independent investigation. Many reports can be handled internally, but an external investigator is usually needed where senior people are implicated or the issue could be material.

What should a board do with the findings of a review?
Agree an action plan with clear owners and deadlines, report progress back to the board, and where appropriate explain to shareholders or regulators what has changed as a result.

Related Guides and Services

Board reviews, oversight and independent challenge.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Need Stronger Independent Oversight?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to discuss adding independent non-executive directors, an audit committee chair or a senior independent director to your board. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.