Boards lose effectiveness gradually. Directors who were the right choice five years ago may not fit the challenges the business faces now. Discussion becomes comfortable, challenge softens and the board’s skills drift away from the company’s strategy. Nobody decides that the board should underperform. It happens because refreshing a board involves honest assessment and difficult conversations with people who have often served loyally, and those are easy to put off.
This guide is about the practical work of fixing the problem once you have recognised it. If you are still weighing up whether to act, our article on the cost of waiting too long to refresh your board sets out what delay costs. If you need to understand how a formal review works, our guide to independent board evaluations covers the process in detail. Here we focus on what comes between the diagnosis and the new board: the plan, the conversations, the sequencing and the recruitment.
Signs a Board Is Underperforming
An underperforming board rarely announces itself. More often, the signs are visible to anyone prepared to look:
- Little real challenge. Management proposals are approved with few questions. Votes are unanimous because disagreement has stopped, not because everyone agrees.
- The wrong conversations. Board time goes on operational detail and backward-looking reports, while strategy, risk, culture and succession get squeezed.
- Skills that no longer match the business. The board is strong on the issues of the past and thin on those of the present: digital and technology, regulation, international markets, transactions or a turnaround.
- Disengaged directors. Papers not read, the same directors silent in every meeting, poor attendance at committees.
- Surprises. The board learns about problems from auditors, regulators, customers or the press rather than from its own oversight.
- Loss of confidence outside the boardroom. Investors, lenders or regulators start asking pointed questions about the board itself.
One or two of these signs do not mean the board has failed. Several together, persisting over time, usually mean it needs work. Our guide to what makes a board truly independent in practice covers the behaviours that tend to slip first.
Step 1: Diagnose Before You Act
The temptation, once a chair or investor decides the board is not working, is to go straight to replacing people. That is usually a mistake. Without a clear diagnosis you risk removing the wrong directors, recruiting for the wrong skills and leaving the real problem, which is often how the board works rather than who sits on it, untouched.
The most reliable diagnostic is a proper board review. The UK Corporate Governance Code expects listed boards to review their performance every year and to bring in external facilitation regularly, and private and PE-backed boards increasingly follow the same practice. For a board that is clearly struggling, an externally facilitated review is usually worth the cost, because directors speak more candidly to an outsider and the findings carry more weight. Our page on board evaluations and reviews explains what is involved, and how to run a board evaluation covers an internal approach.
A good diagnosis separates three different kinds of problem:
- Composition: the board lacks particular skills, experience, perspectives or independence.
- Dynamics and process: the right people are present but the chair does not run discussion well, papers are poor, the agenda is wrong or one voice dominates.
- Individual contribution: specific directors are disengaged, over-committed, conflicted or no longer adding value.
Most underperforming boards have some of each. The fix for each is different, and a refresh that only changes membership will not solve a process problem.
Step 2: Map the Gaps with a Skills Matrix
Once the diagnosis is clear, the next step is to set out what the board needs over the next three to five years and compare it with what it has. A board skills matrix is the standard tool. It lists the skills, experience and attributes the strategy demands, scores each director honestly against them and shows where the gaps are.
Done properly, the matrix does three things. It makes the conversation about the board’s needs rather than about personalities. It gives the nomination committee or chair an objective brief for recruitment. And it shows which existing directors still match the board’s future needs and which do not, which makes the harder conversations that follow easier to frame. Our guide to NED skills, competencies and behaviours helps define what to look for beyond technical expertise.
Be wary of a matrix that only measures technical skills. Many underperforming boards have plenty of expertise but lack independence of mind, willingness to challenge or the time to do the job. Those belong in the matrix too.
Step 3: Fix How the Board Works
Some of the improvement can be made with the current board, before anyone leaves. Changes to process are quicker, cheaper and less painful than changes to membership, and they often reveal which directors respond and which do not:
- Reset the agenda so that strategy, risk and people get regular time and operational reporting is pushed into papers.
- Improve board papers so that directors receive concise, decision-focused material in good time.
- Change how meetings run: inviting quieter directors to speak first, using a devil’s advocate on major decisions and holding sessions without management. Our article on creating constructive tension in the boardroom covers these techniques.
- Clarify committee remits and make sure committee chairs report properly to the full board.
- Agree individual development where a director has the right profile but needs to update their knowledge.
Step 4: Have the Conversations with Long-Serving Directors
Refreshing a board almost always means some directors stepping down. This is the hardest part, and it is the chair’s job. A few principles help:
- Base it on the board’s needs, not personal failings. “The board needs different experience for the next phase” is honest, defensible and easier to hear than criticism.
- Talk early and privately. No director should learn about their departure in a board meeting or from a colleague.
- Use natural break points. The end of a term of appointment, a re-election cycle or the nine-year point the Code treats as relevant to independence all give a respectful reason to change. Our article on typical NED term lengths explains how terms work.
- Offer a dignified exit. Agree timing, a handover of committee roles and how the departure will be announced. Many directors, given the chance, will choose to step down rather than be asked.
- Get support where needed. In a family business or where the chair is part of the problem, the senior independent director, a major shareholder or an external adviser may need to lead the conversation.
Directors themselves can help by recognising when it is time to go. Our guide to knowing when it is time for a NED to step down gracefully is written from the director’s side and can be useful to share.
Step 5: Phase the Refresh
Replacing most of a board at once is risky. It loses institutional knowledge, unsettles management and can worry investors and lenders. A phased plan, usually over 12 to 36 months depending on urgency, is almost always better:
- Start with the most important gap. If the chair is the problem, that comes first, because a new chair will shape everything else. Otherwise, start with the skill the strategy most urgently needs.
- Stagger departures and arrivals so committees are never left without experienced members and there is overlap for handover.
- Keep enough continuity. One or two directors with long knowledge of the company are valuable during the transition, provided they support the change.
- Think about committee chairs separately. Losing an audit chair and a remuneration chair in the same year is avoidable with planning.
Fold the plan into a longer-term approach to NED and board succession planning so that the board does not drift back into the same position in five years’ time.
Start a board search
Refreshing an Underperforming Board — 0203 137 2496
Non-executive directors, chairs, committee chairs and trustees for boards across the UK. We reply within one working day, and shortlists typically follow within two to three weeks of an agreed brief. Email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk, or meet us at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF or Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
Step 6: Recruit Properly
The new appointments are where a refresh succeeds or fails. The biggest risk is recruiting more of the same: candidates who are known to existing directors, think the same way and fit comfortably. A refresh needs a deliberate search against the brief from the skills matrix, a wide candidate pool and structured assessment of independence of mind as well as experience. Our article on how to avoid groupthink when selecting NEDs sets out how to do this, and the NED recruitment process for chairs walks through each stage.
Induction matters too. New directors joining a board that is being refreshed need a clear understanding of why the change is happening and what is expected of them, and existing directors need to welcome rather than resist them.
The Chair’s Role
The chair owns the refresh. That means commissioning the diagnosis, agreeing the plan with the board, leading the conversations with departing directors, overseeing the search, usually through the nomination committee, and making sure the new board works. A chair who is unwilling to do this, or who is part of the problem, is often the clearest sign that the refresh has to start at the top. In listed companies the senior independent director leads the review of the chair’s performance and the process for appointing a successor, and private boards often adopt the same approach. Our guides on how to appoint a board chair and how to appoint a senior independent director cover both roles.
When Investors Push for Change
Board refreshes are often triggered from outside. Private equity investors may decide the board of a portfolio company is not strong enough to deliver the value creation plan. Institutional shareholders in a listed company may vote against directors or engage privately with the chair. Lenders may ask for an experienced independent director as a condition of continued support.
Investor pressure can be an opportunity: it gives the chair a mandate for change that might otherwise be resisted. It works best when the board takes ownership of the process rather than having appointments imposed. Agree the diagnosis and the plan with the investor, involve them in defining the brief and keep the search objective. Our guide to how private equity governance works explains how investor rights over board composition usually operate.
How NED Capital Helps
We help chairs, boards and investors refresh boards that are no longer working: defining the brief from the skills gaps, running searches for chairs, independent NEDs and committee chairs, and helping plan phased change so that continuity is protected. Searches are run by our senior search team under founder Adrian Lawrence FCA. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms with a shared network of board directors and senior executives. See our non-executive director recruitment service or board recruitment and succession planning for how we work.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you know if a board is underperforming?
Common signs include little genuine challenge, too much time on operational detail, skills that no longer match the strategy, disengaged directors and problems the board learns about from outsiders. A board review turns those signs into a specific diagnosis.
Should we start a refresh with a board evaluation?
Usually, yes. An evaluation, ideally externally facilitated for a struggling board, shows whether the problem is composition, dynamics or individual contribution, so you change the right things.
How do you ask a long-serving director to step down?
The chair should talk to them early and privately, base the conversation on what the board needs next rather than personal failings, use a natural break point such as the end of a term and agree a dignified exit with a proper handover.
How quickly should a board be refreshed?
In most cases over 12 to 36 months, phased so that committees keep experienced members and knowledge is handed over. Faster change may be needed where there is a crisis or regulatory pressure.
Who should lead a board refresh?
The chair, supported by the nomination committee. Where the chair is part of the problem, the senior independent director or major shareholders may need to lead the first stage.
How do we avoid recruiting more of the same?
Recruit against an objective brief from the skills matrix, search widely beyond existing directors’ networks and use structured interviews that test independence of mind as well as experience.
Related Guides and Services
Board effectiveness, succession and recruitment.
Diagnosis
Board Reviews
→ Independent Board Evaluations
→ How Effectiveness Reviews Work
→ Board Skills Matrix
Renewal
Succession and Tenure
→ The Cost of Waiting
→ Board Succession Planning
→ The Nomination Committee
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Sister practice of FD Capital
Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director who has worked with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.
Refresh Your Board with Confidence
Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to discuss a board refresh, a new chair or independent NEDs in confidence. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
NED Capital | Part of FD Capital Group | Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder