Do Smaller Companies Really Need Non-Executive Directors?

An honest answer for smaller-company owners: not every small firm needs a NED — but at the right stage the right one is transformative. When it is worth it.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
About Us

Do Smaller Companies Really Need Non-Executive Directors?

Do Smaller Companies Really Need Non-Executive Directors?

The Short Answer

No law requires a smaller private company to have a non-executive director. Under the Companies Act 2006 a private company needs only one director, and many small businesses run perfectly well with the owner or owners alone on the board. The UK Corporate Governance Code applies to listed companies, not to small private ones.

So the honest answer is: not always. A very early business, or one whose owner has no plans to grow, raise money or sell, may not need a NED yet. But for many smaller companies there comes a point where an experienced, independent voice adds more than it costs. The question is less whether a smaller company needs a NED than when, and what kind.

This article focuses on that timing and on the practical, cost-effective ways smaller companies can get board-level help. If you run a family business, our separate guide on whether private and family businesses need a NED covers the ownership and family dynamics in more depth. If you are weighing a NED against an advisory board, see advisory boards vs NEDs by growth stage.

Why Owners Are Sceptical, and Why That Is Reasonable

Owners of smaller companies often see non-executive directors as something for large listed companies: formal, expensive and slow. That scepticism is healthy. A NED appointed for the wrong reasons can add cost and process without adding value. Common mistakes include:

  • appointing a friend or former colleague who will not challenge the owner;
  • appointing someone impressive but with no experience of the company’s stage or sector;
  • appointing a NED because an adviser suggested it, without being clear what the role is for;
  • expecting a NED to do executive work the business has not yet hired for.

Each of these is avoidable. The fix is to start with the problem the business needs to solve, not with the title. Our guide to what a non-executive director is and why you would hire one explains what the role can and cannot do.

Five Moments When a First NED Makes Sense

In our experience, smaller companies benefit most from a NED at moments of change. If one of these applies to your business, it is worth taking seriously.

1. Taking outside investment. Once a business has external shareholders, whether angel, venture or private equity investors, the board becomes accountable to people who are not running the business. Investors often expect, and sometimes require, an independent director. A NED who has been through fundraising can help prepare the business, manage investor relationships and make sure the board meets its obligations to all shareholders. Our article on building a board that attracts investors covers this.

2. Scaling quickly. Growth stretches systems, people and decision-making. An owner who has made every decision personally now needs a management team and a board that can hold it to account. A NED who has seen businesses through this stage can spot problems early, from cash and controls to hiring and culture. See the role of a NED in fast-growth scale-ups and building your first board as a scale-up.

3. Professionalising management. When an owner starts hiring a finance director, operations director or managing director, the board’s role changes from making decisions to overseeing the people who make them. A NED helps set up that structure and gives the owner a sounding board while letting go.

4. Planning succession. Whether the plan is to hand over to family, promote a management team or bring in an external leader, succession is one of the hardest transitions a smaller company faces. An independent director brings objectivity to decisions that owners find personal and difficult. Our article on why succession planning fails without NED oversight explains the risks.

5. Preparing for sale. Buyers pay for businesses that can run without the owner, have reliable numbers and have clean governance. A NED appointed two or three years before an intended exit can help build exactly that. Our guide to high-growth boards before private equity covers the governance buyers look for.

Signs You Might Not Need One Yet

Equally, some situations suggest waiting. A NED may be premature if:

  • the business is very early and the priority is finding product-market fit, not governance;
  • the owner has no plans to grow significantly, raise money or sell;
  • the real gap is executive capacity, for example a finance function, rather than board oversight;
  • the owner is not ready to hear challenge and act on it.

The last point matters most. A NED is only useful if the owner wants an independent view. If you would ignore uncomfortable advice, a NED will cost money and change nothing. In that case, an informal mentor or a paid adviser on a specific project may be a better starting point.

Where the gap is executive rather than board-level, a part-time or interim executive is often the right answer first. Our sister firm FD Capital places part-time and interim finance directors, and Exec Capital covers other C-suite roles.

Cost-Effective Options for Smaller Companies

Board-level help does not have to mean a large fee or a formal board. Smaller companies have several options, and the right one depends on the problem.

A single part-time NED. The most common route. One experienced independent director attending a handful of board meetings a year, plus time between meetings, gives the owner challenge and support without building a full board. Fees are generally set by the size of the business and the time required; our NED salary guide and guide to how NED fees are structured explain how this works, including the option of equity for some growth businesses.

An independent chair. For businesses with several shareholders or a management team that needs leading at board level, an independent chair can be more valuable than a NED. The chair runs the board, manages the relationship with investors and supports the CEO.

An advisory board. An advisory board gives access to expertise without appointing statutory directors. Advisers carry no directors’ duties and have no vote, which suits some early-stage businesses. The trade-off is less accountability and less weight with investors. Our board advisory recruitment page and guide to appointing a board adviser explain the options.

A fixed-term appointment. Some businesses appoint a NED for a defined period, such as through a fundraising or a sale process, with a clear review point. This keeps commitment and cost predictable for both sides.

Whatever the route, smaller companies should check their articles of association, any shareholder agreement and any investor consent rights before appointing a director, and consider directors’ and officers’ insurance for the new appointee.

Low-Cost Options Compared

Option Typical commitment Best for
A single NED with a modest fee About one day a month Owners who want independent challenge on the board
An independent chair One to two days a month Businesses preparing for investment or a sale
An adviser or mentor Ad hoc Owners who want advice without changing the board
An advisory board Quarterly meetings Businesses needing several areas of expertise
A NED paid partly in equity As agreed Early-stage companies short of cash

Jodie says

One good NED is often enough

Smaller companies sometimes think they need a full board of non-executives. In our experience one well-chosen NED, with the right skills for the next stage, usually makes the biggest difference.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

What Good Looks Like in a Smaller Company

A NED in a smaller company does not need the full apparatus of a listed board. But a few basics make the difference between an appointment that adds value and one that drifts.

A clear purpose. Write down why you are appointing a NED and what success looks like after a year. That purpose should drive the role description, the person you choose and how you review the appointment. Our guide on what to include in a NED job description helps.

Regular, proper board meetings. Even a small board benefits from a regular rhythm: an agenda, papers sent in advance, minutes and actions. Monthly management accounts with a short commentary are usually enough to start.

Real independence. The NED should have no financial dependence on the owner and no close personal ties. Independence is what allows challenge, and challenge is what you are paying for. Our article on why UK companies need independent NEDs explains why it matters.

The right experience for your stage. A former FTSE 100 director may not be the best fit for a business with twenty staff. Look for someone who has seen businesses at your stage and the next one, ideally in a related sector.

Access between meetings. Much of a smaller-company NED’s value comes from conversations between board meetings: a call before a big decision, a review of a key hire, an introduction. Agree how this will work at the outset.

An annual review. Once a year, owner and NED should discuss honestly whether the appointment is working and what should change. Many good appointments evolve as the business does.

Directors’ Duties Still Apply

Whatever the size of the business, a non-executive director appointed to the board is a director in law, with the same duties as executive directors. An owner should explain this to any prospective NED, and a prospective NED should understand it before accepting. The government’s guidance on running a limited company summarises directors’ responsibilities, and our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director goes into more detail.

For the owner, the practical point is that a good NED will ask to see accurate financial information, will want to understand risks, and will raise concerns if the business runs into difficulty. That is a feature, not a problem. It is part of what makes the business stronger and more attractive to lenders, investors and buyers.

How to Find the Right NED

Many smaller companies find their first NED through personal networks. That can work, but it tends to produce people the owner already knows and who may find it hard to challenge. A wider search usually gives a better choice and a more independent appointment.

The process does not need to be complicated: define the gap, write a short role description, search beyond your immediate network, meet a shortlist, take references and agree clear terms. Our page on how to recruit a non-executive director sets out how we run this, and our private company board search service is designed for owner-managed and investor-backed businesses. If you are planning to expand abroad, see also how NEDs help SMEs expand internationally.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a small company legally required to have a non-executive director?
No. A private company needs only one director under the Companies Act 2006, and there is no legal requirement for any of them to be non-executive. Investors, lenders or regulators may ask for one, but that is a commercial or regulatory requirement, not a general legal one.

What size of company should appoint a NED?
There is no size threshold. Stage and circumstances matter more than headcount or turnover. A small business raising investment or preparing for sale may benefit more than a larger one with stable ownership and no plans to change.

How much time does a NED spend with a smaller company?
It varies with the business and the role, but smaller-company NEDs usually attend regular board meetings and give time between meetings for calls and specific issues. Agree the expected commitment, and what happens in a busy period, before the appointment.

Can a small company pay a NED in shares?
Some growth businesses offer equity alongside or instead of cash fees. This can align interests, but it can also affect the director’s independence and has tax and legal implications. Take advice before agreeing it, and see our guide to how NED fees are structured.

Should I choose an advisory board or a NED?
An advisory board gives expertise without directors’ duties or a vote, which can suit early-stage businesses. A NED sits on the board, carries legal responsibility and usually carries more weight with investors and lenders. Our comparison by growth stage sets out the trade-offs.

What if the NED and the owner disagree?
Disagreement is part of the job, and handled well it improves decisions. The owner, as shareholder, usually has the final say on ownership matters, but board decisions should be made properly with concerns recorded. If disagreement becomes persistent and unproductive, it is better to review the appointment openly than to let it drift.

Related Guides and Services

Helping owner-managed and growing businesses build the right board.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Thinking About Your First NED?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk for a confidential conversation about whether a non-executive director is right for your business, and when. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.