How the Role of Non-Executive Directors Differs Across the UK, US, and EU
More boards now operate across borders than ever before. UK companies take on US investors or list in New York. European groups appoint British directors to their supervisory boards. Experienced UK NEDs are approached for roles on boards elsewhere. In each case, the assumption that “a board is a board” can cause real problems.
The legal structure of the board, who holds which powers, how directors are paid and what happens when things go wrong all vary between systems. A NED who has served for years on UK boards will recognise the core of the job anywhere, but will find that the shape of the role, and the risks attached to it, can be quite different.
This guide is about board structures and the role itself. If you want to understand how the terms “non-executive” and “independent director” are used in each market, and how the independence tests compare, read our companion article on non-executive vs independent director terminology. For the UK definitions specifically, see the difference between an independent and a non-executive director.
The Common Ground
Before the differences, it is worth being clear about what is shared. In all three systems, non-executive or outside directors:
- are not involved in day-to-day management;
- monitor and challenge the executives running the business;
- bring outside experience to strategy and risk;
- staff the committees where independence matters most, especially the audit committee; and
- are expected, in listed companies, to include a substantial number of directors who are independent of management and major shareholders.
The European Commission’s 2005 Recommendation on the role of non-executive or supervisory directors set out much of this shared thinking for EU member states, and it still underpins many national codes. The differences lie in structure, enforcement and culture.
The United Kingdom: One Board, Shared Duties
The UK uses a unitary board. Executive and non-executive directors sit together on one board and owe the same legal duties under the Companies Act 2006, including the duty to promote the success of the company under section 172 and the duty of care, skill and diligence. There is no separate oversight body. NEDs provide oversight from inside the same board that approves strategy, which means they share collective responsibility for its decisions. Our guide to the legal duties of a NED in the UK covers these in detail.
For listed companies the framework is the UK Corporate Governance Code, applied on a comply-or-explain basis. Key structural features include:
- Separate chair and chief executive. The Code says these roles should not be held by the same person, and that the chair should be independent on appointment. The chair leads the board; the CEO runs the business.
- A senior independent director. One independent NED acts as a sounding board for the chair and an intermediary for other directors and shareholders. Our guide to appointing a senior independent director explains the role.
- Independent committees. Audit, remuneration and nomination committees are made up wholly or mainly of independent NEDs.
- Cash fees. NED pay is a fixed fee, and the Code says it should not include share options or performance-related elements.
The UK approach relies heavily on investor engagement and disclosure rather than detailed rules, and private litigation against NEDs is relatively uncommon compared with the US.
The United States: Unitary Board, Rules-Based Framework
US companies also have a single board, but the surrounding framework is different in three important ways.
Combined CEO and chair roles are common
Unlike the UK, the US has no general expectation that the chair and CEO roles be split. Many large US companies combine them. Where they do, the board usually appoints a lead independent director to chair sessions of the independent directors, act as a channel to the chair-CEO and represent the independent view to shareholders. The lead independent director is the nearest US equivalent to the UK senior independent director, but in practice it often carries more weight because it is the main counterbalance to a combined chair-CEO. Our article CEO vs chairman: who really holds the power? discusses why the UK separates the roles.
Independence is set by rules, not a code
US listed company boards are governed by stock exchange listing standards and federal securities law rather than a comply-or-explain code. Exchange rules require a majority of independent directors and independent audit, compensation and nominating committees, and federal law sets specific independence requirements for audit committee members under SEC Rule 10A-3. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act also places significant weight on the audit committee’s oversight of financial reporting and internal controls. Compliance is a matter of meeting the rule rather than explaining a departure.
Litigation shapes behaviour
The biggest practical difference for directors is legal exposure. US directors face shareholder derivative claims and securities class actions much more often than their UK counterparts. Corporate law, much of it shaped by the state of Delaware where many large companies are incorporated, protects directors who act on an informed basis and in good faith through the business judgement rule. The volume of litigation still makes board processes, minutes and the documentation of decisions much more defensive than many UK directors are used to. Directors’ and officers’ insurance and company indemnities are central to any US appointment. For the UK equivalent, see our guide to D&O insurance for non-executive directors.
Equity is a normal part of director pay
US outside directors are commonly paid a significant part of their compensation in company stock, often restricted shares or share units. That is the reverse of the UK position, where share options and performance-related pay for NEDs are discouraged. A UK NED joining a US board should expect equity to form part of the package and should understand the dealing restrictions that come with it. Our guide to NED share options explains why UK practice differs.
The European Union: More Than One Model
There is no single EU board model. Company law is largely national, and member states fall broadly into three groups.
Two-tier boards
Germany is the best-known example. A German stock corporation has a management board, which runs the business, and a separate supervisory board, which appoints and oversees the management board and approves major decisions. Supervisory board members are not members of the management board and cannot be at the same time. In this model, the “non-executive” role is a seat on a separate body with its own legal powers, rather than a place on a shared board. The German Corporate Governance Code sets expectations for supervisory boards of listed companies on a comply-or-explain basis similar to the UK’s.
Other countries, including the Netherlands and Austria, have historically used two-tier boards for many larger companies, although some now allow companies to choose a one-tier structure.
One-tier boards
Many member states use a unitary board broadly similar to the UK’s, with executive and non-executive members sitting together. Practice on separating the chair and CEO varies; in some countries combined roles remain common.
Choice of model
Some countries, notably France, let companies choose between a one-tier board and a two-tier structure with a management board and supervisory board. A UK director approached for a European role should always establish which model the company uses, because the powers and responsibilities of the seat depend on it.
Employee representation
A major difference from both the UK and US is employee representation on the board. In Germany, larger companies must reserve seats on the supervisory board for employee representatives, and in the largest companies employees elect half the supervisory board. Several other member states have their own forms of board-level employee representation. For a director from the UK, sitting alongside employee-elected colleagues on the same board changes the dynamics of discussion, particularly on restructuring, pay and workforce issues. UK boards instead engage with the workforce through methods set out in the UK Code, such as a designated NED or a workforce advisory panel.
Board composition rules
EU law also sets some board composition targets that do not apply in the UK. The EU directive on gender balance among directors of listed companies requires member states to set targets for the share of the under-represented sex among non-executive directors, or among all directors, of listed companies. UK listed companies instead report against diversity targets in the FCA’s listing rules on a comply-or-explain basis.
How the Systems Compare
| Feature | UK | US | EU (varies by country) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Board structure | Unitary | Unitary | Unitary, two-tier or a choice of either |
| Chair and CEO | Expected to be separate | Often combined, with a lead independent director | Separate in two-tier boards; varies in one-tier |
| Governance basis | Comply or explain | Listing rules and securities law | National law plus national codes |
| Employee seats | No; workforce engagement instead | No | Required in some countries, e.g. Germany |
| NED pay | Cash fees; no options | Cash plus significant equity | Mostly cash fees |
| Litigation risk | Relatively low | High | Varies; generally lower than US |
What This Means for UK Companies
UK companies most often meet these differences in three situations.
- US investors or a US listing. Investors used to US boards may expect equity-based director pay, a different approach to the chair role or more legalistic board processes. A board preparing for a US listing will need to meet US independence rules for its audit committee as well as UK expectations.
- European subsidiaries. A UK group with a German or Dutch subsidiary may need to staff a supervisory board, including alongside employee representatives, and should brief any UK directors it nominates on how that role differs.
- International NEDs on UK boards. Directors from the US or Europe may bring different assumptions about pay, process and the chair-CEO relationship. A good induction covers the UK model explicitly. Our article on NED induction and training covers what that should include.
Our international NED recruitment team works with boards that need directors who understand more than one system, and our guide to board structure, composition and independence covers the UK design questions in more depth.
What This Means for Directors
If you are a UK NED considering a role on an overseas board, ask:
- Which board model does the company use, and is my seat on a management, unitary or supervisory board?
- What legal duties and liabilities attach to the seat under local law, and what D&O cover and indemnities are in place?
- Is the chair also the CEO? If so, who leads the independent directors?
- How will I be paid, and what dealing restrictions apply to any equity?
- Are there employee representatives on the board, and how does the board work with them?
- How much time does the role really need, including travel and time-zone differences? Our article on directors serving across borders covers the practical side.
The core skills of a good NED travel well. The assumptions about structure, pay and risk do not, and taking local legal advice before accepting an overseas appointment is always sensible.
Before You Join a Board Outside the UK
- Liability. Ask how directors’ liability works in that country and whether the D&O policy covers claims brought there.
- Securities law. A US listing brings SEC reporting and, for audit committee members, specific independence rules.
- Board structure. On a two-tier board you may be joining a supervisory board with no direct management role.
- Employee representation. Some EU boards include employee-elected members, which changes how the board works.
- Tax and fees. Check where your fee is taxed and whether the company will withhold tax.
- Time and travel. Agree how many meetings are in person and the time zones involved.
Jodie says
UK candidates are in demand overseas
International boards often ask us for UK directors because they understand a unitary board and the UK Code. The candidates who do best are the ones who take time to learn the local rules before they start, rather than assuming the UK model applies.
For international executive roles, our sister company at fdcapitalint.com handles recruitment.
Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the NED role the same in the UK, US and EU?
The core purpose, independent oversight of management, is the same. The structures differ: the UK and US use unitary boards, while some EU countries use two-tier boards in which non-executives sit on a separate supervisory board. Pay, the chair’s role and legal risk also vary.
What is a two-tier board?
A two-tier board separates management from oversight. A management board runs the company and a supervisory board appoints and oversees it. Germany is the best-known example. Members of the supervisory board are not part of management.
Why do US companies combine the chair and CEO roles?
US practice has never required the roles to be split, and many boards believe a combined role gives clear leadership. Where the roles are combined, boards usually appoint a lead independent director to balance the chair-CEO’s influence. UK practice takes the opposite view and expects the roles to be separate.
Are US directors paid in shares?
Commonly, yes. US outside directors often receive a large part of their pay in company stock. In the UK, the Corporate Governance Code says NED pay should not include share options or performance-related elements, so cash fees are the norm.
Do EU boards include employee representatives?
In some member states, yes. Germany requires employee representatives on the supervisory boards of larger companies, and several other countries have their own forms of board-level employee representation. The UK and US do not require employee directors.
Is it riskier to be a NED in the US?
Generally the litigation risk is higher. US directors face shareholder derivative claims and securities class actions more often than UK directors, which makes D&O insurance, indemnities and careful board processes particularly important.
Related Guides and Services
Board structures, independence and international appointments.
Independence
Terms and Tests
→ NED vs Independent Director
→ Independent vs Non-Executive (UK)
→ What Is a Senior Independent Director?
Governance
How UK Boards Work
→ What Is Corporate Governance?
→ The UK Code and NEDs
→ Board Structure and Composition
Recruitment
Appointing Across Borders
→ International NED Recruitment
→ Listed Company NEDs
→ NED Recruitment
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Sister practice of FD Capital
Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.
Appointing a Director With International Experience?
Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about your board. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
NED Capital | Part of FD Capital Group | Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of NED Capital and a Fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name. He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London, and has more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect businesses with the independent Non-Executive Directors they need to provide challenge, governance and strategic oversight — and personally leads candidate assessments for board-level appointments.