D&O Insurance for Non-Executive Director

How to read a directors' and officers' (D&O) insurance policy as a non-executive director: limits and how they are shared, dedicated Side A cover, the definitions that decide who and what is covered, the exclusions that matter, allocation, run-off and notification, and the questions to put to the company secretary or broker.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
NED Course

D&O Insurance for Non-Executive Director

D&O Insurance for Non-Executive Director

Every non-executive director is told that the company has D&O insurance. Far fewer have read the policy. That is understandable: policies are long, written in insurance language, and usually arranged by the finance team and a broker long before a new NED arrives. But the wording decides whether you are protected when a claim comes, and the details that matter most are the ones that are easy to skip.

This article is a practical guide to reading and, where possible, improving a D&O policy from a non-executive director’s point of view. If you want the wider picture first, covering why NEDs need protection, deeds of indemnity and the Companies Act rules, start with our overview of what insurance non-executive directors need. This article goes into the policy itself. It is general guidance, not insurance or legal advice, and directors with a specific question should speak to the company’s broker or their own adviser.

Why the Wording Matters to a NED

A non-executive director carries the same legal duties as an executive director. Our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director sets them out, and our page on NED responsibilities and legal duties puts them in context. Claims can come from shareholders, a liquidator, a regulator, creditors, employees or the company itself, and the costs of defending an investigation can be substantial even where the director has done nothing wrong. Our article on when NEDs can be personally liable for company debts explains some of the routes to personal exposure.

A NED’s interests are not always the same as the company’s or the executives’. Claims often arise when a company is in difficulty, when the board is divided, or after a change of control, which are exactly the times when a policy’s limits, exclusions and priorities are tested. That is why it is worth reading the policy before you need it.

1. Limits and How They Are Shared

A D&O policy has an overall limit of indemnity, which is the most the insurer will pay. In most policies that limit is shared by everyone insured: all directors and officers, and often the company itself. One large claim, or several claims against different directors, can use up the limit before your own defence costs are paid. Defence costs usually come out of the same limit as damages, so a long investigation can erode the cover.

Questions to ask:

  • What is the overall limit, and is it an aggregate limit for the policy year?
  • Does it cover the company’s own losses as well as the directors’, and if so, could a claim against the company exhaust it?
  • Are there any sub-limits, for example for investigations, pollution or particular jurisdictions?
  • When was the limit last reviewed against the size and risk profile of the business?

2. Side A, B and C, and Dedicated Side A Cover

Most policies have three parts. Side A pays directors directly where the company cannot or will not indemnify them, for example because it is insolvent or the law prevents it. Side B reimburses the company when it has indemnified a director. Side C, sometimes called entity cover, protects the company itself, usually for securities claims in listed companies.

For a NED, Side A is the most important part, because it is the cover that responds when the company is in no position to help. The risk is that Side B and Side C claims use up the shared limit first. Some companies buy a separate, dedicated Side A policy that only protects individual directors and cannot be eroded by the company’s own claims. Ask whether one exists, and if it does not, whether the board has considered it. Many policies also include an order of payments clause, which says individual directors are paid before the company. Check that it is there.

3. The Definitions: Who and What Is Covered

The definitions section is where cover is won or lost. Three definitions deserve attention.

  • Insured person. Check that it clearly includes non-executive directors, former directors, directors of subsidiaries, and directors appointed to outside boards at the company’s request. If you sit on a subsidiary board or were nominated to an investee company, make sure you are covered there.
  • Claim. A wide definition includes not just lawsuits, but written demands, regulatory and criminal investigations, formal interviews, disqualification proceedings and extradition. Many NEDs’ most likely exposure is an investigation rather than a lawsuit, so check that investigation costs are covered and from what point.
  • Loss. Check what counts as loss: defence costs, damages, settlements, and costs of attending interviews or responding to regulators. Fines and penalties are often excluded or uninsurable, which is normal, but the policy should be clear.

4. The Exclusions That Matter

Every policy has exclusions. Some are standard and reasonable; others can leave a NED unexpectedly exposed.

  • Conduct exclusions. Policies exclude deliberate fraud, dishonesty and illegal personal profit. Good wording applies these only after a final judgment or adjudication, so defence costs are paid until then. Check the trigger.
  • Severability. The conduct or knowledge of one director should not be imputed to others. Without this, an innocent NED could lose cover because of an executive’s dishonesty.
  • Insured versus insured. Many policies exclude claims by one insured against another, to stop collusion. Good wording carves back claims brought by a liquidator or administrator, derivative claims by shareholders, employment claims and whistleblowing-related claims. For a NED, the liquidator carve-back is especially important.
  • Prior and pending claims. Claims arising from matters known before the policy started are usually excluded. If you are joining a board with known problems, check how those matters are treated, and whether a previous policy will respond.
  • Major shareholder exclusions. Some policies exclude claims by large shareholders. In a private equity-backed or family company, where a major shareholder is the most likely claimant, this can matter a great deal.

These points link closely to the work a NED should do before accepting a seat. Our due diligence checklist before joining a board covers the wider picture.

5. Allocation

When a claim involves both covered and uncovered matters, or both insured and uninsured parties, the costs have to be divided. That is allocation. A policy that is silent on allocation can lead to disputes at the worst possible time. Look for a clear allocation clause, ideally one that favours paying defence costs in full while the dispute is resolved, and for an advancement of defence costs clause, so costs are paid as they are incurred rather than at the end.

6. Run-Off Cover

D&O policies are usually written on a claims-made basis: the policy in force when the claim is made responds, not the one in force when the act happened. Claims against directors often come years after they leave. If the company is sold, restructured or enters insolvency, the policy may be cancelled or converted into a run-off policy, and a director who has left may have no say.

Ask what happens to cover after you leave the board and after a change of control. Many policies convert automatically into run-off on a change of control, covering past acts for a period but not new acts. A well-advised NED will ask for a commitment in the letter of appointment or deed of indemnity that the company will maintain cover for former directors for a reasonable period. Our guides to negotiating board role terms and your first NED contract cover how to raise this.

7. Notification

Because cover depends on when a claim is made and notified, the notification conditions matter. Policies require the insured to notify claims, and often circumstances that might give rise to a claim, within set timescales. Late notification can prejudice cover.

Find out who is responsible for notifying the insurer, usually the company secretary or finance director, and how directors should report concerns that might become claims. If you become aware of a potential claim against you personally, do not assume someone else will notify it. In a crisis, the board should consider notification early. Our article on the NED’s role when a company faces insolvency covers one of the situations where this is most urgent.

The Deed of Indemnity Alongside the Policy

Insurance works together with the company’s indemnity. Under the Companies Act 2006, a company may buy insurance for its directors (section 233) and may give a qualifying third party indemnity (section 234), but other indemnities against a director’s liability to the company are generally void. A deed of indemnity gives the NED a direct contractual right against the company, which matters if the articles change or the relationship sours. Our insurance overview explains how the two fit together.

Questions to Ask the Company Secretary or Broker

  • Can I see the full policy wording, not just the schedule or a summary?
  • What is the overall limit, is it shared with the company, and are there sub-limits?
  • Is there dedicated Side A cover, or an order of payments clause?
  • Does the definition of claim include regulatory and criminal investigations, and from what stage?
  • How do the conduct exclusions operate, and is there full severability?
  • Does the insured versus insured exclusion carve back claims by liquidators, administrators and shareholders?
  • Is there a major shareholder exclusion?
  • Are outside directorships and subsidiary boards covered?
  • What happens to cover after I leave and on a change of control, and will the company commit to maintaining run-off cover?
  • Who notifies claims and circumstances, and how should I report a concern?
  • When was the cover last reviewed, and has the board discussed it?

Asking these questions is not awkward or unusual. Experienced chairs expect thoughtful NEDs to ask them, and a company that cannot answer them clearly is telling you something. If the answers are not satisfactory and the company will not improve the position, that is a factor in deciding whether to walk away from a board appointment. With regulators paying more attention to individual directors, as our article on why NEDs are increasingly targeted by regulators explains, investigation cover has become one of the most important features to check.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who pays for D&O insurance?
The company normally buys and pays for the policy, which covers its directors and officers. The Companies Act permits this. Some directors also buy personal cover to top up the company’s policy.

What is Side A cover?
Side A pays directors directly when the company cannot or will not indemnify them, for example because it is insolvent. It is the most important part of the policy for a non-executive director.

Does D&O cover regulatory investigations?
Many policies cover the costs of responding to regulatory and criminal investigations, but the definition of claim varies. Check whether investigations are covered and from what stage. Fines and penalties are often excluded or uninsurable.

What happens to my cover when I leave the board?
Policies are usually claims-made, so you rely on whatever policy is in force when a claim is made. Ask the company to commit to maintaining cover for former directors, and check what happens on a change of control.

Can one director’s fraud remove cover for everyone?
It should not. Look for a severability clause, which stops one director’s conduct or knowledge being imputed to the others.

Should I ask to see the policy before joining?
Yes. It is a reasonable request, and the policy wording, not the summary, is what decides your cover. Ask for it alongside the letter of appointment and deed of indemnity.

Related Guides and Services

Protection, liability and the terms of a board role.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director who has worked with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Considering a Board Appointment?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about non-executive roles, or register as a candidate. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Shortlists typically in two to three weeks once the brief is agreed

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.