When a NED Should Walk Away from a Board Appointment

When should a non-executive decline a board seat or resign on principle? The warning signs before accepting, the grounds for resigning after, and how to walk away well.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Recruitment Process Outsourcing

When a NED Should Walk Away from a Board Appointment

When a NED Should Walk Away from a Board Appointment

The Short Answer

Before accepting a board role, the warning signs that should give serious pause are weak or opaque finances, a culture that does not want challenge, a chair or chief executive who dominates, poor information flow, and inadequate directors’ and officers’ (D&O) insurance or indemnity. Honesty about your own time and expertise matters too. After joining, the grounds for resigning on principle are narrower but real: being consistently ignored on matters that matter, ethical or legal concerns the board will not address, a board that cannot function, or discovering the business is materially not what it seemed.

Walking away is rarely the first step. The right sequence is to raise concerns, press them through the chair and the board, and make sure unresolved concerns are recorded in the minutes. When those routes are exhausted, resignation is the final safeguard of a director’s integrity and independence. A director who could never contemplate resigning has, in a sense, already given up their leverage.

This article is about walking away because something is wrong. It is distinct from two related decisions covered elsewhere: whether a role suits you in the first place, addressed in how to decide if a NED role is right for you, and the natural end of a tenure that has run its course, covered in knowing when it’s time to step down gracefully.

Why the Decision Matters

Every non-executive director carries the same legal duties as an executive director. Under section 174 of the Companies Act 2006, a director must exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence. That is judged both against what can reasonably be expected of anyone in the role and against the director’s own knowledge, skill and experience. Being part-time or non-executive is not a defence. If a company drifts into difficulty, directors who should have known what was happening can face claims, including for wrongful trading under section 214 of the Insolvency Act 1986, and disqualification.

That is why the decision to join, and the decision to stay, deserves the same rigour as any other risk decision. Our guides to the legal duties of a NED in the UK and time, liabilities and pay set out the exposure in more detail. This article focuses on the judgement calls.

Before Accepting: Red Flags in Due Diligence

The easiest walk-away is the one you make before you join. A proper appraisal of the board and the business is the best protection a director has, and our due diligence checklist before joining a board sets out what to request. These are the warning signs that should give real pause.

The finances do not add up

Read the last two or three years of filed accounts, the latest management accounts, the budget and the cash forecast. Late filing, qualified or emphasis-of-matter audit opinions, repeated auditor changes, growing reliance on a single lender or customer, and management accounts that are hard to reconcile to the statutory numbers all deserve direct questions. If the answers are vague, treat the vagueness as the answer. A company already close to insolvency is a particularly difficult place for a new NED, because the duties shift toward creditors and the room to act is limited.

The culture does not want challenge

Ask the chair what they want from the role and listen carefully. If the non-executives are described as a sounding board, a network or a credibility signal for investors, rather than as directors expected to scrutinise and challenge, you may be joining to endorse rather than oversee. Speak to other directors if you can. Ask how the board handled its last serious disagreement. A board that cannot name one is either unusually aligned or not having the debates it should.

The chair, or the chief executive, dominates

Boards work when the chair runs the board and the chief executive runs the business, with real challenge between them. Warning signs include a combined chair and chief executive role without a strong senior independent director, a founder or majority owner who treats the board as advisory, or a chair who controls the agenda tightly and discourages discussion outside it. Our article on CEO versus chairman covers how that balance should work.

Information flow is poor

A NED’s effectiveness depends on what the board is told. Ask to see a recent board pack, redacted if necessary. Thin papers issued the night before, no risk register, minutes that record decisions but no debate, and committees that rarely meet all suggest a board that will struggle to know what is happening. Ask whether you would have access to senior management below the executive team, to the auditors and to independent advice at the company’s expense.

Protection is inadequate

Ask for the D&O policy schedule, the limit of cover, whether it is shared across a group, the main exclusions and how long run-off cover would last after you leave. Ask whether the company will give you a deed of indemnity to the extent the law allows. A board that cannot answer clearly is asking you to take on personal liability without basic safeguards. Our guides to D&O insurance for non-executive directors and negotiating board role terms explain what to look for.

Something is not being disclosed

Ask about litigation, regulatory investigations, the reasons the previous director left and any matters the board expects to deal with in the next year. Ask the outgoing director directly if you can. Evasion on any of these is a reason to stop and think, however attractive the role.

You cannot give it what it needs

The last test is honesty with yourself. If you cannot realistically commit the time, including the extra time a difficult period demands, or you lack the knowledge to add real value, declining is the responsible choice. The UK Corporate Governance Code makes the same point for listed boards: Provision 15 says boards should take into account other demands on directors’ time when making appointments.

After Joining: When to Resign on Principle

Resigning from a board you have joined is a graver step than declining one, and it should never be a reaction to ordinary disagreement. A non-executive who resigns every time they lose a vote is not exercising independence but avoiding the work of persuasion. Losing arguments is part of board life. There are, though, circumstances where staying becomes untenable.

You are consistently ignored on matters that matter. Not the occasional lost argument, but a settled pattern in which serious concerns are brushed aside and your presence is being used to lend legitimacy to decisions you cannot support.

An ethical or legal concern is not being addressed. Evidence of misreporting, a compliance failure, unsafe practices or conduct that crosses a line, where the board declines to act despite the matter being properly raised. In regulated firms, there may also be obligations to the regulator to consider, and directors should take advice.

The board cannot function. It is so dominated by one person, so divided or so dysfunctional that real governance has become impossible and your efforts cannot restore it. Our article on why governance failures often start with weak NED oversight shows how these situations develop.

The business is not what it seemed. You discover after joining that material facts were misrepresented or withheld.

Your own position has changed. A conflict of interest you cannot manage, covered in handling conflicts of interest as a NED, or a change in your circumstances that means you can no longer give the role proper attention.

The common thread is that your ability to fulfil your duties as a director has been compromised in a way you cannot fix from the inside, and continuing to serve would mean lending your name to something you cannot stand behind.

Resignation is not always the safe option

One caution. Resigning does not end a director’s responsibility for what happened while they were on the board, and leaving at the moment a company most needs independent oversight can sometimes be the wrong choice, both for the company and for the director. When a business is in financial difficulty, a director who stays, insists on proper advice and pushes for the right steps may be better placed than one who leaves. These situations are fact-specific, and it is worth taking independent legal advice before deciding.

After Joining: Red Flags and Responses

Red flag First response
Information is withheld from the board Ask the chair for it formally and minute the request
Decisions are taken outside the board Raise it with the chair and the company secretary
Concerns are not minuted Ask for your concern to be recorded
The company may be trading while insolvent Take independent advice immediately
You are asked to approve something you believe is wrong Vote against, ask for it to be minuted and consider your position

Jodie says

Leaving well protects your reputation

Directors who resign on principle and do it properly, with written reasons and proper notice, are usually respected for it. We have seen such directors go on to strong appointments, because chairs value their judgement.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

How to Walk Away Well

If you reach the point of resigning, how you do it matters, both for your own protection and because a resignation handled properly carries far more weight with the board than one handled badly.

Raise concerns first, and escalate. Put concerns clearly to the chair, then to the full board if needed. Give the organisation a genuine chance to respond. Our guide to managing disagreements between NEDs and executives covers how to do this constructively.

Make sure dissent is recorded. Provision 8 of the UK Corporate Governance Code says that where directors have concerns about the operation of the board or the management of the company that cannot be resolved, those concerns should be recorded in the board minutes. That record protects your position and is often the point at which a board finally takes a concern seriously. The same discipline is good practice on any board, listed or not.

Put your reasons in writing. Provision 8 also says that on resignation a non-executive director should give the chair a written statement setting out any such concerns, for circulation to the board. Keep it factual and measured. Take your own professional advice on what to say, to whom, and whether any regulator or auditor needs to be informed.

Handle the formalities. Resign in writing in line with your letter of appointment and the company’s articles. The company must notify Companies House of a change in its directors within 14 days under section 167 of the Companies Act 2006. Check that it does.

Confirm your cover continues. Make sure the run-off element of the D&O policy will cover you for claims arising from your time on the board, and keep copies of board papers and minutes from your tenure, subject to your confidentiality obligations.

Done this way, with concerns raised, dissent recorded and an exit that is considered, walking away is not a failure but the final exercise of the independence the role exists to provide.

This article is general guidance on non-executive appointment decisions, not legal advice. Directors facing these situations should take their own professional advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the red flags before accepting a NED role?
The main warning signs are finances that are late, unclear or hard to reconcile; a board that does not want challenge; a dominant chair or chief executive; thin or late board papers; inadequate D&O insurance or indemnity; and evasive answers about litigation, regulators or why a predecessor left.

When should a non-executive director resign?
When serious concerns are consistently ignored, when ethical or legal issues are not addressed after being properly raised, when the board cannot function, or when the business turns out to be materially different from what was represented. Resignation should come after concerns have been raised, escalated and recorded, not before.

Does resigning end a NED’s liability?
No. A director remains responsible for decisions made while they were on the board. Resignation stops future exposure, but run-off D&O cover and proper records of your concerns remain important after you leave.

Should a NED’s concerns be recorded in the board minutes?
Yes. The UK Corporate Governance Code says unresolved concerns about the operation of the board or the management of the company should be recorded in the minutes, and that a resigning non-executive should give the chair a written statement of any such concerns for circulation to the board.

How much notice does a NED have to give?
It depends on the letter of appointment and the company’s articles. Many letters of appointment set a short notice period for non-executives. Once a director has resigned, the company must notify Companies House within 14 days.

Can a NED resign if the company is in financial difficulty?
Yes, but it needs care. Leaving does not remove responsibility for what happened while you served, and staying to insist on proper advice and the right steps can sometimes be the better course. Take independent legal advice before deciding.

Related Guides and Services

Deciding which boards to join, and when to leave.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Weighing Up a Board Appointment?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk it through in confidence. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.