What Is a Senior Independent Director (SID)?

What a senior independent director does, why boards appoint one, and how the SID supports and challenges the chair under the UK Corporate Governance Code.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Independent and Ned

What Is a Senior Independent Director (SID)?

What Is a Senior Independent Director (SID)?

Most descriptions of the senior independent director stop at the definition. The SID is an independent non-executive director who acts as a sounding board for the chair, an intermediary for the other directors and an alternative point of contact for shareholders. That is accurate, but it says little about what the role feels like when it is actually used. For long stretches the SID looks like any other independent NED. Then something happens, and the board, the shareholders or the chief executive turn to one person.

This article is about those moments. It sets out the situations in which the SID is expected to step in, what good practice looks like in each, and how a newly appointed SID can prepare before they are needed. For the definition and the place of the role in the board structure, see our guide to what a senior independent director is. If you are choosing one, our guide on how to appoint a senior independent director covers the process, and for regulated firms our page on the SMF14 senior independent director function explains the FCA dimension.

At an FCA-regulated firm the SID can be a senior manager in their own right; SMF Capital explains what the FCA expects from an SMF14 senior independent director.

The Role in One Paragraph

Provision 12 of the UK Corporate Governance Code says the board should appoint one of the independent non-executive directors to be the senior independent director. The Code describes the SID as a sounding board for the chair and an intermediary for the other directors and shareholders, and expects the non-executive directors, led by the SID, to meet without the chair present at least annually to appraise the chair’s performance. Everything else the SID does in practice grows out of those expectations. Outside listed companies there is no requirement to have a SID, but many private equity-backed, regulated and larger private boards appoint one because the same problems arise wherever a chair holds significant power.

Situation One: Appraising the Chair

This is the one SID task that happens every year, and it sets the tone for everything else. The chair runs the board’s evaluation of itself and of individual directors, but someone has to evaluate the chair. That is the SID’s job.

In practice the SID gathers views from the other non-executive directors, usually in one-to-one conversations or through the board evaluation questionnaire, and seeks the views of the executive directors, particularly the chief executive and the finance director. The SID then holds a meeting of the non-executives without the chair, discusses the findings, and gives the chair honest, balanced feedback in private.

Practical points for a new SID:

  • Agree the process with the chair in advance, so it is a normal part of the board calendar rather than an event.
  • Ask specific questions: how well the chair runs meetings, manages the agenda, draws out quieter directors, handles disagreement and works with the chief executive.
  • Separate what you have heard from what you think, and be clear which comments are shared by several directors.
  • Deliver the feedback face to face, and agree any actions with the chair rather than imposing them.

Where the board uses an external evaluator, the SID usually works with them on the chair’s section. Our guides to how board effectiveness reviews work and independent board evaluations explain the wider process.

Situation Two: Chair Succession

A chair should not lead the search for their own successor. The Code reflects this by saying the chair should not chair the nomination committee when it is dealing with the appointment of their successor, and in practice the SID very often leads that process instead.

Leading a chair succession means agreeing the timetable with the board, working with the nomination committee to define what the next chair needs to bring, deciding whether internal candidates should be considered, appointing and briefing a search firm, and managing the interviews and the board’s decision. It also means managing the outgoing chair, who may have firm views about who should follow them. Our article on how a nomination committee chooses new directors covers the committee’s role, and our guide to appointing a board chair sets out the process step by step.

If the chair leaves unexpectedly, the SID may also need to step in while a successor is found, or to help the board decide whether an interim chair is needed. Thinking about this before it happens, as part of the board’s succession planning, saves time when it matters.

Situation Three: Shareholders With Concerns

Shareholders normally talk to the chair and the chief executive. The SID is the alternative channel when those routes have failed, or when the concern is about the chair or the chief executive themselves. In a listed company that might be an institutional investor unhappy about strategy, pay or board composition. In a private equity-backed company it might be a minority investor or a management shareholder who feels unheard.

When a shareholder approaches you as SID:

  • Listen carefully and take a note of the concern, without committing the board to anything.
  • Be careful about information: you cannot share inside information or give one shareholder material information that others do not have.
  • Tell the chair that the contact has happened, unless the concern is about the chair and there is good reason not to yet.
  • Report back to the board, so the concern is considered properly and the shareholder receives a considered response.

The SID’s job is not to take sides, but to make sure shareholder concerns reach the board and are dealt with. Our article on how non-executive directors protect shareholder interests sets the wider context.

Situation Four: Conflict Between the Chair and the Chief Executive

The relationship between the chair and the chief executive is the most important on any board, and when it breaks down the whole board suffers. The SID is often the person both of them, and the other directors, turn to.

In these situations the SID acts as an honest broker. That means hearing both sides separately, understanding whether the problem is about substance, such as strategy or performance, or about style and boundaries, and helping the two of them find a way forward. Sometimes the answer is a clearer division of responsibilities. Sometimes it is a frank conversation that neither has been willing to have. Occasionally it becomes clear that the relationship cannot work, and the board has to decide which of them should go. In that case the SID usually leads the board’s discussion, because the chair cannot do so impartially.

Our article on who really holds the power between the CEO and the chairman explains the two roles, and our guide to managing disagreements between NEDs and executives covers the broader skills involved.

Situation Five: A Crisis Involving the Chair

Most crises are led by the chair. The SID becomes central when the chair is part of the problem, is conflicted, or is unable to act. Examples include a serious allegation about the chair’s conduct, a conflict of interest that prevents the chair from taking part in a decision, a dispute between the chair and a major shareholder, or the chair’s sudden illness.

In these cases the SID may need to convene the independent directors, decide whether independent legal or other professional advice is needed, lead any investigation into the chair’s conduct, and make sure the board takes decisions properly without the conflicted director. The SID should keep careful records, because decisions taken in these circumstances are often scrutinised later. Our guide to handling conflicts of interest explains how the board should deal with a conflicted director.

Situation Six: Whistleblowing That Reaches the Top

Most whistleblowing reports concern people well below the board, and the board’s role is to oversee the arrangements rather than investigate each case. But some reports involve the chief executive, the chair or another director, and the ordinary routes may not be appropriate. Many boards name the SID, or the chair of the audit committee, as the escalation point for concerns about the most senior people.

If a report reaches you, make sure the person raising it is protected, agree with the other independent directors how it will be investigated and by whom, keep the subject of the concern out of decisions about the investigation, and record what was done. In regulated financial services firms there may be a separate whistleblowers’ champion, and the SID should know how the two roles fit together. Our article on the NED’s role in promoting an ethical culture covers speak-up arrangements more widely.

SID and Deputy Chair Compared

Senior independent director Deputy chair
Required by the UK Code? Yes, for companies applying the Code No
Main purpose A sounding board for the chair and an intermediary for directors and shareholders To stand in for the chair
Leads the chair’s appraisal? Yes Not usually
Must be independent? Yes Not necessarily
Can be the same person? Yes, some boards combine the two roles Yes

Jodie says

SID candidates need quiet authority

When we search for a SID, we look for directors other board members already turn to. It is a role that depends on trust, and it is usually clear in references who has it.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Preparing for the Role: Guidance for a New SID

The worst time to work out how to be a SID is in the middle of one of the situations above. A newly appointed SID can prepare in several practical ways:

  • Agree your role in writing. Ask for the SID’s responsibilities to be set out by the board, ideally in a short role description alongside the chair’s and chief executive’s, so there is no argument later about your mandate.
  • Build the relationships early. Spend time with the chair, the chief executive, the company secretary and each of the non-executives, so you are already trusted when you need to be.
  • Know the shareholders. Understand who the major shareholders are and how they engage, and in a listed company consider meeting key investors so they know who you are.
  • Understand the escalation routes. Know the whistleblowing policy, the matters reserved for the board and how independent advice can be obtained at the company’s expense.
  • Agree the chair’s appraisal process in your first year, so the annual meeting of non-executives without the chair is routine.
  • In regulated firms, check approval. Where the SID role is a designated senior management function, you will need regulatory approval before taking it on. Our FCA-regulated board governance hub explains the regime.

What Makes a Good SID in Practice

The qualities that matter are the ones these situations demand. A good SID has the respect of the chair without being the chair’s ally, and the trust of the other directors without being their spokesperson. They are discreet, because much of the role involves confidential conversations. They are calm under pressure, because they are often called on when relationships are strained. And they have the courage to say difficult things to the chair, privately and constructively, when no one else will.

The role can also be isolating, particularly during a dispute involving the chair. Our article on the loneliness of independent NEDs discusses how directors in that position can find support without compromising their independence.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does a senior independent director actually do day to day?
Most of the time the SID works as an ordinary independent non-executive director. The extra role becomes visible in specific situations: the annual appraisal of the chair, chair succession, shareholder concerns, disputes between the chair and chief executive, crises involving the chair and serious whistleblowing reports.

Is a SID required by law?
No. There is no legal requirement. The UK Corporate Governance Code expects companies that apply it to appoint a SID, and many private, PE-backed and regulated boards choose to appoint one as good practice.

Who appraises the chair?
Under the Code, the non-executive directors, led by the SID, meet without the chair at least annually to appraise the chair’s performance, taking account of the views of the executive directors.

Does the SID lead the search for a new chair?
Very often, yes. The Code says the chair should not chair the nomination committee when it deals with the appointment of their own successor, and boards commonly ask the SID to lead the process.

Can shareholders contact the SID directly?
Yes. The SID is an alternative point of contact for shareholders, particularly when contact through the chair or chief executive has not resolved a concern or the concern is about one of them.

Does a SID need FCA approval?
In some regulated firms the SID role is a senior management function and needs approval before the person can perform it. Whether it applies depends on the firm’s category, so check the position for the specific firm.

Related Guides and Services

The senior independent director and the top of the board.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Appointing a Senior Independent Director?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to discuss a SID, chair or independent non-executive appointment in confidence. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.