NED vs Trustee vs Advisory Board Member: What’s the Difference?

NED, trustee or advisory board member? The three differ sharply in legal duties, personal liability and how each is appointed. A clear UK guide to all three.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Independent and Ned

NED vs Trustee vs Advisory Board Member: What’s the Difference?

NED vs Trustee vs Advisory Board Member: What’s the Difference?

The three titles are used loosely, and people moving into board work often assume they are much the same thing. They are not. The differences decide your legal duties, your personal liability, how you are appointed, whether you are paid and what the organisation can reasonably expect of you. Before accepting any board-level role, it is worth being clear which of the three it really is, because the title on the invitation is not always a reliable guide.

This article is a comparison hub. It sets out the three roles side by side and points to our more detailed guides on each. If you are weighing up a trustee role against a company NED role in particular, our article on the difference between a trustee and a NED goes deeper. If you are a business deciding between an advisory board and a formal board seat, see advisory boards vs NEDs by growth stage and advisory board vs board of directors.

The Three Roles in Brief

Non-executive director

A non-executive director is a director of a company. In law there is no separate category of “non-executive” director: a NED is appointed to the board in the same way as any other director, is registered at Companies House and owes the same general duties under the Companies Act 2006. What makes the role non-executive is that the director does not hold a management job in the business. They oversee, challenge and support the executive team rather than run the company day to day. Our guide to what a non-executive director is covers the role in full.

Charity trustee

A trustee is a member of the governing body of a charity. Trustees are collectively responsible for the charity’s direction, management and control, and they owe duties under charity law, overseen in England and Wales by the Charity Commission. Where the charity is a charitable company, its trustees are also company directors, so both sets of rules apply. Most trustees are unpaid volunteers. In terms of responsibility, the trustee role is the charity-sector equivalent of a director’s seat.

Advisory board member

An advisory board is a group of people who give advice to a company’s founders, chief executive or board. It has no formal power: it does not vote on board decisions, it cannot bind the company and its members are not directors. An advisory board member offers expertise, contacts and perspective, and the company can take or leave that advice. The arrangement is set out in a contract or letter rather than in company law, and it can be flexible in a way a board seat cannot.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature Non-executive director Charity trustee Advisory board member
Legal status Company director Member of a charity’s governing body (also a director if it is a charitable company) Contractual adviser, not an officer
Main rules Companies Act 2006, the company’s articles, governance codes where relevant Charity law and Charity Commission guidance, plus company law for charitable companies The advisory agreement
Vote on decisions Yes Yes No
Duties Statutory directors’ duties Trustee duties under charity law Contractual, plus general duties of care in giving advice
Personal exposure Real, in specific circumstances Real, in specific circumstances Low, unless the adviser acts as a director in practice
Pay Usually a fee Usually unpaid; expenses reimbursed Fee, equity or unpaid, by agreement
Who appoints The board or shareholders, under the articles Under the charity’s governing document The company’s management or board
Typical organisations Listed, private, PE-backed and regulated companies Charities, including charitable companies and CIOs Start-ups, scale-ups and businesses wanting specialist input

Legal Status and Duties

The single most important difference is legal accountability. A NED and a trustee both sit on the body that is legally responsible for the organisation. An advisory board member does not.

As a company director, a NED owes the general duties in the Companies Act 2006: to act within the company’s powers, to promote the success of the company, to exercise independent judgement, to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence, to avoid conflicts of interest, not to accept benefits from third parties, and to declare interests in proposed transactions. These apply in full from the day of appointment. Our guide to the legal duties of a NED in the UK covers each duty and how it applies to non-executives.

Trustees owe duties under charity law. The Charity Commission’s guidance The Essential Trustee (CC3) sets out what trustees must do, including ensuring the charity pursues its purposes for the public benefit, complying with its governing document and the law, acting in the charity’s best interests, managing its resources responsibly, acting with reasonable care and skill, and ensuring it is accountable. For a charitable company, these sit alongside the directors’ duties.

An advisory board member, by contrast, owes the duties set out in their agreement and the ordinary duty to take care in the advice they give. They are not responsible for the organisation’s decisions, because they do not make them.

Liability and the Shadow Director Risk

Directors and trustees are not personally liable for the organisation’s debts simply because of their role. Limited liability protects them in the ordinary course. But both can face personal exposure in specific circumstances, such as wrongful trading when a company is close to insolvency, breach of duty, or misapplication of charity funds. Our article on whether NEDs are personally liable for debts sets out the main exceptions, and our guide to what insurance NEDs need covers D&O insurance and indemnities.

Advisory board members are in a much safer position, provided the role stays advisory. The risk arises when an adviser starts to act like a director: directing the business, taking decisions or being someone whose instructions the board is accustomed to follow. The Companies Act treats such a person as a “shadow director” under section 251, and some directors’ duties and liabilities can then apply. Professional advice given in a professional capacity is excluded, but the protection depends on the adviser genuinely advising rather than directing. Advisers should keep their role clearly advisory, and companies should be careful not to treat an advisory board as a decision-making body.

Pay and Time Commitment

NEDs are normally paid a fee, which is treated as employment income because a directorship is an office. Fees vary with the size, complexity and risk of the organisation and with any committee or chair responsibilities. Our NED salary guide gives indicative ranges, and how NED fees are structured explains the components.

Most charity trustees are unpaid. They can be reimbursed for reasonable expenses, and trustees can be paid for their trusteeship only where the governing document permits it or the Charity Commission authorises it, which is unusual. For many people, unpaid trusteeship is a deliberate choice, both as a contribution to a cause and as a route into board experience.

Advisory board terms are whatever the parties agree. Some advisers receive a fee, some receive equity in an early-stage business and some give their time for free.

Time commitment follows a similar pattern. A NED role typically involves board meetings, committee work, reading papers and contact between meetings, with extra time in a crisis. Trustee roles vary widely with the size of the charity. Advisory roles are usually lighter and more flexible. Our article on how many days a year a NED role takes covers the director’s commitment in more detail.

Independence and Who You Serve

A NED’s duty is owed to the company, and in listed and regulated companies many NEDs are expected to be independent of management and major shareholders. Our guide to independent vs non-executive directors explains the distinction.

A trustee’s duty is owed to the charity and its purposes, not to any group that appointed them. Even a trustee nominated by a particular body must act in the charity’s best interests.

An advisory board member serves whoever engaged them, usually the founders or management. That makes advisory boards useful for getting candid, specialist input, but it also means an adviser does not provide the independent oversight that investors, lenders and regulators often look for in a board.

Questions to Ask Before Accepting Each Role

Role Key questions
Non-executive director What is the company’s financial position? What D&O cover is there? How many days will it really take?
Charity trustee Is the charity incorporated? What are its reserves and risks? Has it made any serious incident reports?
Advisory board member What exactly am I advising on? Will I be asked to make decisions? How is my role described to others?

Jodie says

Advisers sometimes drift into directors

We see advisory roles where, over time, the adviser starts attending board meetings, taking part in decisions and being described as a director. That can create the shadow director risk without the protection a formal appointment brings.

If an advisory role grows, it is usually better to make it a proper board appointment.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

Which Role Is Right for You?

For individuals, the choice depends on what you want from board work.

  • Choose a NED role if you want real governance responsibility, are prepared to accept the duties and exposure that come with it, and want to build a paid board career. The NED Career Hub sets out the routes in.
  • Choose a trustee role if you care about a cause, want genuine board experience and are comfortable that it will usually be unpaid. Our trustee roles page and trustee recruitment service cover current opportunities.
  • Choose an advisory role if you want to contribute expertise flexibly, perhaps alongside an executive career, without taking on directors’ duties. Our board advisory recruitment service connects advisers with businesses.

Many people hold a mix. A typical portfolio might include one or two NED roles, a trustee seat and an advisory position with a growing business.

Which Should Your Organisation Appoint?

For organisations, the question is what you need.

  • Appoint a NED if you need independent oversight, accountability and challenge at board level, or if investors, lenders or regulators expect it. See how to recruit a non-executive director.
  • Appoint trustees if you are a charity: they are your governing body. Our guide to appointing a charity trustee explains the process.
  • Appoint advisers if you need specialist knowledge or contacts without changing your board’s composition or control. Our guide to appointing a board adviser covers how to do it well.

Some businesses start with an advisory board and convert one or more advisers into NEDs as they grow. That can work well, provided everyone understands the change in duties and exposure when an adviser joins the board.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a trustee the same as a non-executive director?
The roles are similar in responsibility, but they sit in different legal frameworks. A trustee governs a charity under charity law and is usually unpaid. A NED is a company director under company law and is usually paid. Trustees of charitable companies are also company directors.

Does an advisory board member have legal duties?
Not directors’ duties. An advisory board member owes the obligations in their agreement and a duty to take care in their advice. The risk is that, if they start directing the business, they could be treated as a shadow director.

Can an advisory board member vote on board decisions?
No. An advisory board has no formal decision-making power. Only directors vote on board decisions.

Are charity trustees paid?
Usually not. Trustees can be reimbursed for reasonable expenses, but payment for acting as a trustee needs authority in the governing document or from the Charity Commission.

Which role is the best first step into board work?
Many people start with a trustee or advisory role to gain board experience before taking a company NED role. A trustee seat in particular gives real governance responsibility and is valued by boards hiring first-time NEDs.

Can I hold all three roles at once?
Yes, many people do. You need to manage your time carefully and check for conflicts of interest between the organisations you serve.

Related Guides and Services

Choosing the right board role for you or your organisation.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Looking for a Board, Trustee or Advisory Role?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk about NED, trustee or advisory appointments, or register as a candidate. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.