Why Non-Executive Directors Are Increasingly Targeted by Regulators

Why regulators increasingly hold non-executive directors personally accountable — the post-crisis shift to individual responsibility, SMCR, and what it means for NED

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Fractional Executives for Tech Businesses

Why Non-Executive Directors Are Increasingly Targeted by Regulators

Why Non-Executive Directors Are Increasingly Targeted by Regulators

Non-executive directors were once thought of as relatively safe from personal regulatory consequences: part-time overseers, one step removed from running the business. That view is out of date. When something goes wrong today, regulators and investigators look beyond the company and its executives to ask what the board knew, what it asked and what it did. Non-executives are part of that question.

This article explains why the environment has changed, which regimes drive it in the UK, and what a NED can do to stay on the right side of it. It is general information rather than legal advice. For the specific duties that sit underneath it, read our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director in the UK, and for financial exposure see whether non-executive directors are personally liable for debts.

The Shift From Collective to Individual Accountability

For a long time, when a company failed or misbehaved, the consequences fell mainly on the organisation: fines, remediation and reputational damage. Individual directors were pursued much less often, and non-executives least of all. The financial crisis and a series of later corporate failures changed that. Inquiries repeatedly found that responsibility spread across a whole board had left nobody clearly accountable, and that boards had failed to challenge executives who were taking excessive risks.

SMF Capital explains the duty of responsibility and reasonable steps, the test regulators apply to senior individuals.

The policy response has been consistent: make it clearer who is responsible for what, and make it easier to act against individuals when they fall short. Some of the changes apply only to regulated firms. Others apply to every company director. Together they mean that a NED’s personal conduct in the boardroom now matters more than it did.

Our article on why governance failures often start with weak NED oversight looks at the patterns these inquiries found. This article looks at the regulatory machinery that followed.

Driver 1: The Senior Managers and Certification Regime

In financial services, the clearest expression of individual accountability is the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR). It requires the people who hold specified senior roles to be approved by the regulator before they start, to have documented responsibilities, and to meet conduct rules. Senior managers are also subject to a duty of responsibility: if there is a breach in an area they are responsible for, they can be held accountable if they did not take reasonable steps to prevent it.

Most ordinary non-executives are not senior managers. But several board roles are, depending on the firm: the chair (SMF9), and in larger firms the chairs of the audit, risk and remuneration committees and the senior independent director. For people in those roles, accountability is personal and documented. All non-executives at regulated firms are also subject to conduct rules, and a firm’s board as a whole is expected to oversee areas such as the Consumer Duty.

Our hub on FCA-regulated board governance explains how SMCR works for boards, and our guide to appointing a NED for an FCA-regulated firm covers approval, fitness and propriety and the documents involved. For the specific roles, see our pages on the SMF9 chair and the SMF10 and SMF11 committee chairs.

Driver 2: Director Disqualification

The Insolvency Service investigates the conduct of directors of failed companies and can seek to disqualify those found unfit. Disqualification bars a person from acting as a director, or being concerned in the management of a company, for a period of up to fifteen years. Since 2015, the court has also been able to make compensation orders against disqualified directors for the benefit of creditors who lost out.

Non-executives are not exempt. An investigation will ask whether each director met the standard expected of someone in their position, including whether they read the information available, questioned what they were told and acted when warning signs appeared. A NED who simply relied on the executives without challenge can be found to have fallen short.

Driver 3: Audit and Reporting Oversight

Financial reporting has been another focus. The Financial Reporting Council oversees audit and corporate reporting and can take enforcement action against auditors and against accountants who are members of the professional bodies, which includes many finance directors and audit committee members. The government had planned to replace the FRC with a new statutory regulator with stronger powers, including direct sanctions against directors of large companies for serious reporting failures. In early 2026 the government confirmed it would not proceed with that legislation, so the FRC continues on its existing basis.

That does not reduce the pressure on audit committees. The 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code strengthened the board’s responsibility for risk management and internal controls, including a declaration on the effectiveness of material controls. Our article on how the UK Corporate Governance Code impacts NEDs explains what the Code expects, and what an audit committee actually does covers the committee’s work in practice.

Driver 4: Pensions

Where a company sponsors a defined benefit pension scheme, The Pensions Regulator has powers that can reach beyond the company itself. Its anti-avoidance powers can, in some circumstances, be used against people connected with the employer, and the Pension Schemes Act 2021 introduced criminal offences for conduct that puts members’ accrued benefits at risk or avoids an employer’s debt to a scheme. These offences are not limited to executives.

For a NED, the practical point is that major transactions, dividends, refinancings and restructurings in a company with a defined benefit scheme need proper consideration of the scheme’s position, and the board’s reasoning should be recorded.

Driver 5: Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency

The Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023 changed the landscape in two ways relevant to boards. First, it made it easier to hold companies criminally liable for economic crimes committed by their senior managers. Second, it created a new corporate offence of failure to prevent fraud, which came into force on 1 September 2025 for large organisations. A company can be liable if an employee or agent commits fraud intending to benefit it, unless the company had reasonable prevention procedures in place.

The offence is a corporate one, but the board owns the question of whether prevention procedures are reasonable. NEDs, particularly on audit and risk committees, should expect to be asked how the board satisfied itself that they were. Our guide to the three lines of defence is a useful framework for that oversight.

The same Act introduced identity verification for directors at Companies House. It is an administrative requirement rather than a sanction, but it reflects the same direction of travel: the people who run and oversee companies are expected to be identifiable and accountable.

Driver 6: Higher Expectations of Boards Generally

Beyond specific regimes, expectations of boards have risen across the board. Investors, lenders and the public expect directors to understand cyber risk, culture, conduct and sustainability as well as the numbers. When a crisis hits, the board’s preparation is examined as closely as management’s response. Our article on the NED’s role in cyber crisis response shows how that plays out in one area.

Which Regulator, Which Risk

Regulator or body Main risk for a NED
Financial Conduct Authority Enforcement under the SMCR and conduct rules in regulated firms
Insolvency Service Disqualification for unfit conduct, and compensation orders
Financial Reporting Council Oversight of audit and reporting, with powers under its enforcement procedures
The Pensions Regulator Contribution notices where a scheme is materially harmed
Companies House New powers to query and reject information, and identity verification for directors
Health and Safety Executive Prosecution of directors where an offence involved their consent, connivance or neglect

Jodie says

Candidates are asking about personal risk

More of the experienced candidates we speak to ask about personal regulatory risk before they ask about the fee. They want to know about the D&O policy, the indemnity and whether the firm is under any regulatory scrutiny.

Boards that answer those questions openly find it easier to attract strong candidates.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

What This Means for NEDs

None of this is a reason not to serve. Most NEDs complete long board careers without any regulatory contact. But it does change how a careful NED approaches the role.

  • Understand your regime before you join. Find out whether the role is a senior management function, what you will be responsible for and what approval is needed.
  • Read, question and record. The common thread in every regime above is whether a director did what a reasonable director in their position would have done. Reading the papers, asking hard questions and making sure the minutes record them is the best evidence you can have. Our guide on constructive tension in the boardroom covers how to challenge well.
  • Insist on good information. If the board does not get the information it needs, say so formally and keep pressing until it does.
  • Check your insurance and indemnity. D&O insurance can meet defence costs in regulatory investigations, subject to the policy terms. Our article on what insurance non-executive directors need explains what to check.
  • Keep your own records. Keep copies of board papers and your own notes for as long as your letter of appointment and confidentiality obligations allow. Investigations can begin years after the events in question.
  • Know when to step back. If your concerns are not being addressed, you may need to escalate or, ultimately, resign. Our guide on when a NED should walk away covers that decision.

Our article on time commitment, liabilities and pay gives a broader view of what the role really involves.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are non-executive directors more likely to face regulatory action than before?
Regulators are more willing to look at individual directors than they were, and several regimes now make individual accountability explicit. That said, regulatory action against non-executives remains uncommon, and directors who engage properly are well placed.

Does the Senior Managers and Certification Regime apply to all NEDs?
No. It applies only at regulated financial services firms, and within those only certain board roles, such as the chair and, in larger firms, committee chairs and the senior independent director, need approval as senior managers. Other non-executives at regulated firms are subject to conduct rules.

Can a non-executive director be disqualified?
Yes. The disqualification regime applies to all directors. A non-executive can be disqualified if their conduct, including a failure to oversee or challenge, makes them unfit to be concerned in the management of a company.

What happened to the plan for a new audit regulator?
The government had planned to replace the Financial Reporting Council with a new statutory regulator with powers over directors of large companies. In early 2026 it confirmed it would not proceed with that legislation, and the FRC continues under its existing powers.

Is the failure to prevent fraud offence a personal offence for directors?
No, it is a corporate offence. But boards are responsible for deciding whether the company’s fraud prevention procedures are reasonable, and NEDs should expect to show how they oversaw that.

Does D&O insurance cover regulatory investigations?
Many policies cover defence costs in regulatory investigations, but cover, limits and exclusions vary, and fines and penalties are often not insurable. Read the policy and ask the company’s broker before you join.

Related Guides and Services

Accountability, regulation and protection for directors.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Strengthening Your Board’s Oversight?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about non-executive director recruitment. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.