Why Governance Failures Often Start with Weak NED Oversight
Governance failures are usually told as stories about executives: the aggressive accounting, the over-ambitious acquisition, the risks that were run and hidden. That is only half the story. In a well-governed company, executive misjudgement is caught and corrected by the board before it becomes a crisis. That is what the board is for. So when a company fails through poor governance, the more revealing question is why the non-executive directors, whose purpose is independent oversight and challenge, did not stop it.
The answer is rarely that the NEDs were dishonest. More often they were present, competent in their own fields and well-intentioned, but their oversight was weak. They lacked the expertise to challenge, or the information to know what to challenge, or the independence or will to disrupt a board that had grown comfortable. This article looks at those patterns and what they mean for how boards are built. It complements our guides to the role of NEDs in good corporate governance and what corporate governance is.
SMF Capital explains what the board should expect from the annual compliance report.
The NED as a Line of Defence
The case for independent non-executive directors rests on a simple point: executives cannot be the only check on themselves. They are close to the business, invested in its strategy and often rewarded for short-term performance. All of that can cloud judgement at exactly the moments when clear judgement matters most.
Non-executives exist to supply what executives structurally cannot: distance, independence and a willingness to ask uncomfortable questions. The UK Corporate Governance Code frames the non-executive role around constructive challenge, strategic guidance and holding management to account, and expects at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent non-executives. Company law adds the duty in section 174 of the Companies Act 2006 to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence, which applies to non-executives as fully as to executives.
When that line of defence holds, problems surface early and are dealt with. When it does not, warning signs go unchallenged until the damage is done.
What the Carillion Inquiry Said About the Board
The collapse of Carillion plc, which went into compulsory liquidation in January 2018, is one of the most closely examined UK governance failures. Two House of Commons select committees, the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy Committee and the Work and Pensions Committee, held a joint inquiry and published their joint report on Carillion on 16 May 2018.
The report was severe about the board as a whole, describing it as “both responsible and culpable” for the company’s failure. It also criticised the non-executive directors specifically, saying they had “failed to scrutinise or challenge reckless executives”. The report’s wider criticisms extended to the company’s auditors, its regulators and the government’s own oversight of a major contractor, and readers should go to the report itself for the full findings.
The value of Carillion as a lesson is not that its directors were unusually bad people. It is that the board of a large, listed company, with a full complement of non-executives and the committees the Code expects, still failed to stop the problems that brought the company down. Structure alone did not protect it.
Six Patterns of Weak Oversight
Inquiries into corporate failures, and boards’ own reviews of what went wrong, tend to find the same patterns again and again. None of them is specific to one company or sector.
1. A Dominant Chief Executive
A successful, charismatic chief executive can come to dominate a board. Their record makes challenge feel presumptuous, their command of the detail makes it difficult, and their relationships with individual directors make it uncomfortable. Over time the board defers rather than oversees. The risk is greatest where the chief executive also controls the flow of information to the board, or where the chair is too close to them. Our articles on who really holds the power between the CEO and chair and how that balance shifts in a crisis look at this dynamic.
2. Information Asymmetry
Non-executives depend on management for most of what they know about the business. If board papers are too long, too late, too positive or too aggregated, NEDs can attend every meeting and still not understand the real position. Key judgements, for example on contract accounting, provisions or going concern, can be buried in detail or presented as settled. Weak oversight often begins with a board that accepts the information it is given rather than asking for the information it needs. Our guide to what good board papers look like sets out how to fix this.
3. Groupthink
Boards drawn from similar backgrounds, or that have worked together for a long time, can settle into a shared view that nobody tests. Dissent starts to feel disloyal, and concerns are softened before they are raised. Groupthink is particularly dangerous because it feels like good teamwork from the inside. Our article on how to avoid groupthink when selecting NEDs covers how boards build in different perspectives from the start.
4. Complacency After Success
A long period of good results is one of the most dangerous times for a board. Growth makes aggressive assumptions look justified, and directors who challenged early on may stop doing so once the strategy appears to be working. By the time the numbers turn, the risks taken in the good years are already embedded. Effective NEDs ask hardest about success: how results were achieved, what assumptions they depend on, and what would have to go wrong for them to unravel.
5. Weak or Absent Challenge
Some boards have the right people in the room but challenge is still weak. Directors may lack the specific expertise to question a technical area such as complex contract accounting or treasury risk. They may be reluctant to look uninformed. Or the board’s culture may treat robust questioning as hostile. Challenge is a skill and a behaviour, and boards need to build it deliberately. Our guide to creating constructive tension in the boardroom covers how.
6. Compromised Independence and Conflicts
Independence can erode quietly. Long tenure, close personal relationships with the executive team, financial ties to the company or a sense of obligation to whoever brought a director onto the board can all make challenge harder. The Code’s independence tests exist because these factors are real, and our article on why independence matters more than ever explains why boards are under growing pressure to show it is genuine. Conflicts of interest, which directors must manage under the Companies Act, are a related risk.
Warning Signs a NED Should Not Ignore
Failures rarely arrive without warning. With hindsight, the signs were usually visible to anyone looking for them. Patterns that should prompt a non-executive to ask harder questions include:
- Profits that consistently run ahead of cash generation.
- Growing reliance on judgements, estimates or one-off items to meet targets.
- Rising borrowing, extended payment terms to suppliers or unusual financing arrangements.
- Repeated optimism in forecasts that are later missed.
- Resistance from management to requests for information, or papers that arrive too late to read properly.
- Turnover in the finance function, or disagreements with the auditor.
- Concerns raised by staff, customers, suppliers or regulators that are explained away rather than investigated.
- A board that rarely disagrees and seldom changes a management proposal.
Cash deserves particular attention. Our guide to board oversight of cash flow forecasting explains what a board should expect to see and the questions that expose a weak position.
Oversight Questions That Make a Difference
| Area | Question |
|---|---|
| Cash | Does our cash position match what the profit figures suggest? |
| Contracts | Which contracts are loss-making, and how do we know? |
| Accounting judgements | Which judgements most affect our results, and who challenged them? |
| Pensions | Is the pension deficit under control, and what do the trustees think? |
| Dividends and bonuses | Can we afford them given our cash and obligations? |
| Culture | Do people feel able to raise bad news? |
Jodie says
Boards now test for scepticism
Since high-profile failures, chairs increasingly ask us for NEDs with a reputation for healthy scepticism. We test it in interview by asking candidates what they would want to see before approving a large dividend.
Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital
Lessons for Non-Executive Directors
The patterns above point to a set of practical disciplines for individual NEDs.
- Ask for the information you need, not just what you are given. If you do not understand a key judgement, keep asking until you do, and ask to see the underlying analysis.
- Be most curious when things are going well. Success is when risks build up and challenge falls away.
- Look beyond the board pack. Talk to the finance director, the head of internal audit, the external auditor and people across the business, with the chief executive’s knowledge.
- Make sure concerns are recorded. Raise significant concerns clearly in the meeting and make sure they are minuted. Under the 2024 Code, unresolved concerns about the running of the company should be recorded in the minutes.
- Know when to escalate. If concerns are not addressed, take them to the chair or the senior independent director, consider independent advice and, in serious cases, an independent review.
- Know when to leave. A NED who cannot get a board to act on a serious concern has to consider whether they can stay. Our guide to when a NED should walk away covers that decision.
Lessons for Boards and Chairs
Strong oversight also depends on how the board is built and run.
- Recruit for the skills the risks require. A board overseeing complex contracts, regulated activities or significant financial risk needs directors who can challenge those areas technically. A skills matrix makes gaps visible.
- Protect independence. Refresh the board before tenure and familiarity erode challenge. Our guide to refreshing an underperforming board sets out how.
- Use the chair and SID roles properly. The chair sets the culture of the board; the senior independent director provides a route for concerns about the chair or the chief executive.
- Evaluate honestly. A rigorous independent board evaluation can surface dominance, groupthink and weak challenge before they cause harm.
- Strengthen the committees. The audit committee in particular needs members with recent and relevant financial experience and the confidence to challenge management and the auditor. Our page on audit committee chair recruitment covers what to look for.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are non-executive directors legally responsible for a company’s failure?
All directors owe the same general duties under the Companies Act 2006, including the duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence. Non-executives are not expected to run the business, but they can face criticism, and in some circumstances legal consequences, if they fail to oversee it properly.
What did the Carillion inquiry say about the non-executive directors?
The joint report of the Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and Work and Pensions Committees, published in May 2018, described the board as “both responsible and culpable” for the company’s failure and said the non-executives had “failed to scrutinise or challenge reckless executives”.
Why do competent NEDs still fail to challenge?
Usually because of the conditions around them rather than a lack of ability: a dominant chief executive, poor information, a comfortable board culture, a lack of specific expertise or eroded independence. Strong oversight depends on those conditions being right as well as on the individuals.
What is the most important thing a NED can do to prevent a governance failure?
Insist on understanding the business’s real position, especially cash and the key judgements behind the numbers, and keep asking until the answers make sense. Most failures were visible in the information to a director who was looking closely enough.
How can a board tell whether its oversight is weak?
Signs include a board that rarely disagrees, papers that are long but uninformative, directors who have served together for many years, and concerns that are explained away rather than investigated. A rigorous external evaluation is often the best way to find out.
What should a NED do if they believe the board is not acting on a serious risk?
Raise the concern clearly and make sure it is minuted, take it to the chair or senior independent director, consider independent advice, and if the board still will not act, consider whether they can remain on the board. Staying silent is the one option that offers no protection.
Related Guides and Services
More on board oversight, challenge and independence.
Governance
Effective Oversight
→ Constructive Tension
→ Avoiding Groupthink
→ Why Independence Matters
Board Health
Reviews and Refresh
→ Independent Board Evaluations
→ Independent Reviews
→ Refreshing a Board
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Sister practice of FD Capital
Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.
Strengthening Your Board’s Oversight?
We find independent non-executives with the expertise and confidence to challenge. Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk for a confidential conversation. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
NED Capital | Part of FD Capital Group | Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of NED Capital and a Fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name. He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London, and has more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect businesses with the independent Non-Executive Directors they need to provide challenge, governance and strategic oversight — and personally leads candidate assessments for board-level appointments.