Why Independence Matters More Than Ever for NEDs

Independence is the source of a non-executive director’s value. Why it matters, what quietly erodes it over time, and how a NED protects it — a UK governance view.

  • ICAEW practising certificate holder
  • Permanent, interim and portfolio NEDs
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
London NED

Why Independence Matters More Than Ever for NEDs

Why Independence Matters More Than Ever for NEDs

Ask what a non-executive director is really for and the answer keeps coming back to one word: independence. It is what separates a NED from an adviser, a consultant or a trusted friend of the chief executive. It allows a director to question a strategy the executives are personally invested in, to probe the numbers without worrying about the consequences, and to say the uncomfortable thing that others in the room are thinking but will not voice.

None of that is new. What has changed is the weight now placed on it. Investors, lenders, regulators and auditors all look harder at whether a board can genuinely hold management to account, and they increasingly judge that by the independence of the people around the table. This article looks at why independence matters more now than it did even a few years ago, what erodes it, and how a director keeps it.

It is not a technical guide to the tests. If you want the definitions, our article on the difference between an independent and a non-executive director sets out the UK Corporate Governance Code criteria, and independent vs affiliated NEDs explains the practical distinctions. For why companies appoint independent directors at all, see why UK companies need independent non-executive directors.

Independence Is What Makes a NED Worth Having

Strip independence away and ask what remains. A board member who relies on the company for much of their income, who owes their seat to the chief executive, who has served so long that the company’s way of seeing things has become their own, or whose wealth rises and falls with a single share price, cannot reliably provide disinterested challenge. Their agreement is worth little, precisely because it was never really in doubt.

The law expects every director to exercise independent judgement. Section 173 of the Companies Act 2006 requires it of executives and non-executives alike. Governance independence goes further: it is about being free of the relationships and interests that make objective judgement harder, and being seen to be free of them. The UK Corporate Governance Code builds board composition around that idea, expecting at least half the board, excluding the chair, to be independent non-executives in larger listed companies, and expecting the audit, remuneration and nomination committees to be led by independent directors.

Why It Matters More Than Ever

Investors are looking harder

Institutional investors and proxy advisers now scrutinise board composition closely. They look at tenure, at cross-directorships, at former executives sitting on audit committees and at directors with commercial ties to the business. A board that cannot show a credible independent core invites votes against directors and harder questions at the annual general meeting. Investors are not simply counting heads; they want to see that independent directors actually change outcomes on pay, capital allocation and succession.

Private equity boards rely on it

Independence matters in privately owned businesses too. On a private equity-backed board most seats are held by investor directors and management, whose interests are aligned but not identical. An independent chair or NED is often the only person whose job is to look at the business as a whole: to test management’s forecasts before they reach the investor, to keep lenders confident in reporting, and to manage the tension between the investor’s exit timetable and the company’s longer-term health. Our guide to how private equity governance works covers the dynamics in more detail.

Regulators expect it

In financial services, independence is a regulatory expectation, not just good practice. Under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, independent chairs and committee chairs carry personal accountability, and supervisors want to see boards that challenge executives rather than defer to them. Our hub on FCA-regulated board governance explains how this works for chairs and committee chairs.

Audit and assurance are under the spotlight

Corporate failures in the late 2010s prompted the Kingman review of the audit regulator and the Brydon review of audit quality, and audit and governance reform has stayed on the agenda since. One clear direction has been tougher expectations of audit committees and of boards’ oversight of internal controls. The 2024 Code now asks boards of companies within its scope to declare on the effectiveness of their material internal controls. None of that works without audit committee members who are genuinely independent of management and comfortable challenging the finance function. See what an audit committee actually does for the practical side.

Stakeholders are watching

Employees, customers, lenders and the public all form a view of whether a board is a genuine check on management. When things go wrong, one of the first questions asked is where the independent directors were. Directors who were close to management, long-serving or financially entangled struggle to answer it.

What Quietly Erodes Independence

Independence is rarely lost in a single moment. It wears away gradually, often without the director noticing.

  • Familiarity. Years of working closely with the same executives builds friendships and shared assumptions. Challenge softens because it starts to feel personal.
  • Long tenure. The Code treats service of more than nine years as a factor that may affect independence. The point is not that long-serving directors are compromised, but that the company’s view of the world becomes harder to see from outside. Our guide to typical NED term lengths covers how boards manage this.
  • Financial dependence. If fees from one board become a large share of a director’s income, losing the seat becomes costly, and that can make a director reluctant to rock the boat.
  • Accumulating relationships. Advisory work, consulting arrangements, family links or cross-directorships can each be minor on their own and significant together.
  • Shareholdings and incentives. Performance-related pay or significant equity can align a NED’s interests with short-term share price movements rather than the company’s long-term health.
  • Dependence on the chief executive. A director who owes their appointment to the CEO, or who sees the CEO as their route to future roles, may find it harder to challenge them.

How a NED Protects Their Independence

Protecting independence is partly about structure and partly about behaviour.

Declare and manage conflicts early. Directors have a statutory duty to avoid conflicts and to declare interests in transactions. A NED who is disciplined about declaring interests, and who steps out of discussions when appropriate, keeps their position clear. Our guide to handling conflicts of interest as a NED sets out the process.

Keep a portfolio. Directors with more than one source of income can afford to disagree. A balanced portfolio, without so many roles that time becomes the problem, is one of the best protections of independence.

Do your own homework. Independence depends on information. A NED who relies entirely on management’s papers sees the business through management’s eyes. Site visits, conversations with the auditors, time with the second line and meetings with customers and staff all give an independent view.

Use executive sessions. Many boards hold time without executives present. These sessions let non-executives share concerns openly and agree where to push. The senior independent director plays a key role, including leading the chair’s appraisal.

Be willing to dissent. Independence that is never exercised is not much use. That does not mean opposing for the sake of it, but it does mean being prepared to vote against, to ask for a decision to be deferred, or to have a concern minuted. Our article on creating constructive tension in the boardroom covers how boards make challenge productive.

Review it honestly. Boards are expected to assess each director’s independence every year. The most useful reviews go beyond the formal tests and ask whether a director still behaves independently. An independent board evaluation can surface issues that an internal review misses.

Threats to Independence and the Safeguards

Threat Safeguard
Long tenure Planned rotation and annual review of each director’s independence
Close friendship with the chief executive Private sessions of non-executives without executives
Financial dependence on the fee A portfolio where no single role dominates income
Additional paid work for the company Board approval, disclosure and a review of independence
Equity or incentives Caution over options and performance-related pay
Links with a major shareholder Clear disclosure and treating the director as non-independent where appropriate

Jodie says

Independence comes up in every reference

When we take references for independent NED candidates, we ask referees for an example of the candidate standing apart from the executive team or a major shareholder. Independence is easy to claim and much easier to judge from what someone has actually done.

Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital

What This Means When Appointing a NED

For chairs and nomination committees, the lesson is to think about independence at the point of appointment, not just when the annual review comes round. A good search tests for the obvious conflicts, but it also looks at a candidate’s other commitments, their likely dependence on the role, their relationships with existing board members and their track record of challenge in previous roles.

It also means avoiding the trap of appointing people the board already knows and likes. A board that recruits from its own networks tends to recruit people who think alike. Our guide on avoiding groupthink when selecting NEDs explains how a structured, external process helps.

Our independent non-executive director recruitment service is built around these checks. Searches are led by Jodie Garrington, with oversight from founder Adrian Lawrence FCA, and every candidate is assessed for independence of position and of mind before they reach a shortlist.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does independence matter more for NEDs now than in the past?
Investors, regulators, lenders and auditors all scrutinise boards more closely than they used to, and they judge a board’s ability to hold management to account partly by the independence of its non-executives. Expectations of audit committees and of boards’ oversight of internal controls have also risen.

Does independence matter in private companies?
Yes. The Code does not apply to most private companies, but independent directors are often the only people on a private equity-backed or family board whose role is to look at the business as a whole and balance the interests of investors, management and lenders.

Can a NED lose their independence over time?
Yes. Long tenure, close relationships with executives, growing financial dependence on the role, consulting arrangements or significant shareholdings can all erode independence. That is why boards review it every year.

Is a NED who owns shares still independent?
Holding some shares does not automatically remove independence, but a significant shareholding, or a link to a significant shareholder, is one of the factors the Code says may affect it. Share options and performance-related pay are generally avoided for independent NEDs for the same reason.

How can a NED demonstrate independence in practice?
By declaring conflicts promptly, doing their own homework rather than relying only on management’s papers, using executive sessions, asking searching questions and being willing to dissent and have concerns minuted when they disagree.

Related Guides and Services

Independence, challenge and board effectiveness.

Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital

Fellow of the ICAEW  |  Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate  |  Sister practice of FD Capital

Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.

View Adrian’s ICAEW profile

Looking for Genuinely Independent Directors?

Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to discuss an independent board appointment in confidence. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.

NED Capital  |  Part of FD Capital Group  |  Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder

Start a search

Tell us about your board appointment

Share a few details about your organisation and the director you need. A senior consultant will review your brief and come back to you to talk it through.

  • Reply within one working day, from a consultant who handles board searches every day
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Led by Jodie Garrington, with more than ten years in senior recruitment

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.