7 Governance Mistakes NEDs Should Avoid
When boards fail, the post-mortem rarely uncovers a single catastrophic decision by a non-executive director. What it usually finds is a series of small, ordinary lapses that accumulated over time: questions not asked, papers not read closely, a concern raised in the corridor but never in the meeting, a conflict that was known about but never formally declared. Each lapse looked harmless on its own. Together they left the board unable to see what was happening until it was too late.
That is why governance mistakes are worth naming plainly. They are not exotic, and they are not confined to inexperienced directors. Seasoned NEDs fall into them too, often because familiarity with a company breeds comfort. This article sets out seven mistakes we see repeatedly, explains why each matters, and describes the habits that prevent it. It complements our analysis of why governance failures often start with weak NED oversight, which looks at the patterns from the board’s side, and our guide to the legal duties of a non-executive director in the UK, which sets out the standard every director is held to.
Why These Mistakes Matter
Under the Companies Act 2006, a non-executive director owes the same general duties as an executive director. There is no lighter standard for part-time board members. The duty of care, skill and diligence under section 174 is measured both objectively, against what can reasonably be expected of anyone in the role, and subjectively, against the knowledge and experience the individual actually has. A director with a finance background who misses a warning sign in the accounts may be judged more harshly than one without.
So these mistakes are not just matters of style. They can expose a director personally if things go wrong, they weaken the board’s ability to protect the company, and they undermine the reason a NED was appointed in the first place. Regulators have also become more willing to look at the role of individual directors, a trend we discuss in why non-executive directors are increasingly targeted by regulators.
Mistake 1: Relying on Management Assurance Without Testing It
The most common mistake is also the easiest to slip into. Management tells the board that controls are working, that the forecast is prudent, that the customer complaint was a one-off or that the regulator is satisfied. The board, with limited time and a good relationship with the executive team, accepts the assurance and moves on.
Assurance from management is necessary, but it is not sufficient. Executives are not usually being dishonest. They are often optimistic, close to the problem and naturally inclined to present their own work favourably. The NED’s job is to test what they are told: to ask how management knows, what evidence supports the conclusion, who else has looked at it and what would have to be true for the view to be wrong.
Good practice includes:
- Asking for the underlying data, not just the summary conclusion.
- Using independent sources of assurance, such as internal audit, external audit, compliance monitoring and, where justified, an independent review.
- Meeting people below board level, including the heads of control functions, so the board does not rely on a single channel of information.
- Following up on actions rather than assuming they were completed.
The structure that supports this is often described as the three lines of defence, which our guide to the three lines of defence for non-executive directors explains in detail.
Mistake 2: Not Reading the Papers Properly
Board packs can run to several hundred pages, and they often arrive late. It is tempting to skim the executive summary, rely on the presentation in the meeting and hope that anything important will be raised by someone else. It rarely is.
Reading the papers properly is not optional. It is how a NED forms an independent view before the meeting, rather than reacting to whatever management chooses to emphasise on the day. Many of the most important signals are buried in appendices: a covenant headroom figure, a change in a provision, a rising complaints trend, a line in the risk register that has quietly turned from amber to red.
The practical habits are simple. Block out proper reading time. Read the agenda first and decide what matters most. Look at the numbers before the narrative. Note questions as you go and, where possible, raise factual queries with the company secretary or the paper’s author before the meeting, so meeting time is spent on judgement rather than clarification. Our guide to preparing for your first board pack covers this in depth, and what good board papers look like sets out what to ask for if the papers themselves are the problem.
Mistake 3: Failing to Raise and Record Concerns
Many NEDs have doubts that they never voice properly. They mention a concern privately to the chair, or raise it obliquely in the meeting, and then let it drop when the conversation moves on. If things later go wrong, there is no record that the concern was ever raised.
The 2024 UK Corporate Governance Code expects directors who have concerns about the operation of the board or the management of the company that cannot be resolved to have those concerns recorded in the board minutes. On resignation, a non-executive director should provide a written statement to the chair, for circulation to the board, setting out any such concerns. Even outside listed companies, the principle is sound. Directors’ meetings must be minuted under section 248 of the Companies Act 2006, and the minutes are the evidence of what the board considered.
Raising a concern well means doing it in the meeting, clearly and specifically, explaining what you are worried about and what you would need to see to be reassured. If the concern is not resolved, ask for it to be minuted. That is not an act of hostility; it is part of the job. Our guides to managing disagreements between NEDs and executives and handling the pressure of being the voice of reason look at how to do this without damaging working relationships.
Mistake 4: Ignoring Culture
Boards are comfortable with numbers. Culture feels softer and harder to measure, so it is often left to management or discussed only in general terms. Yet many of the most serious corporate failures have had cultural roots: pressure to hit targets at any cost, a fear of raising bad news, incentives that rewarded the wrong behaviour.
The Code asks boards to assess and monitor culture and to satisfy themselves that policies, practices and behaviour throughout the business are aligned with the company’s purpose, values and strategy. That is a board responsibility, not an HR one. A NED who ignores culture is missing one of the clearest early warning signs of trouble.
Practical ways to engage include visiting sites and talking to staff, reviewing speak-up and whistleblowing data, looking at employee survey results and turnover patterns, asking how incentives are set and what behaviour they reward, and noticing how executives respond when bad news is brought to them. The quiet power of NEDs in shaping organisational culture sets out the levers available, and the NED’s role in promoting ethical culture covers the specific ethical dimension.
Mistake 5: Mishandling Conflicts of Interest
Conflicts of interest are a routine part of board life, especially for directors with portfolios of roles, investments or advisory work. The mistake is not having a conflict; it is failing to identify, declare and manage it properly.
The Companies Act sets out a framework. A director must avoid situations in which they have, or could have, a conflict with the company’s interests unless the conflict has been properly authorised (section 175). A director must declare an interest in a proposed transaction with the company before it is entered into (section 177), and in an existing transaction as soon as reasonably practicable (section 182). The detail varies between private and public companies and depends on the articles.
Common errors include assuming that everyone already knows about an interest so it does not need declaring, failing to update the register of interests when circumstances change, taking part in a discussion that should have been left to others, and treating a conflict as a one-off when it is ongoing. Our guide to handling conflicts of interest as a non-executive director sets out a practical process.
Mistake 6: Taking On Too Much
Non-executive work is often described as part-time, and many directors underestimate how much time it actually takes. Board meetings are only the visible part. Reading, committee work, site visits, strategy sessions, induction, training and calls between meetings add up. When something goes wrong, the time required can multiply overnight.
A NED who has accepted too many roles cannot give each the attention it needs, and the first casualties are usually preparation and follow-up, exactly the activities that make a director effective. The 2024 Code expects directors to have sufficient time to meet their board responsibilities, and expects boards to take other commitments into account when appointing and to give prior approval for additional significant appointments. It also says a full-time executive director should not take on more than one non-executive directorship in a FTSE 100 company or other significant appointment.
The remedy is to be realistic before accepting a role, to keep some capacity in reserve for a crisis and to review the portfolio regularly. Our guides to how many non-executive roles is too many and balancing multiple NED roles without burnout look at both the rules and the practicalities, and the reality of time, liabilities and pay sets out what a typical commitment involves.
Mistake 7: Not Understanding the Regulatory Regime
Every company operates within a regulatory framework, and NEDs are expected to understand the one that applies to the business they oversee. A director on the board of an FCA-regulated firm needs to understand the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, the conduct rules and the firm’s key regulatory obligations. A director of a housing association, a charity, a utility or a healthcare provider faces a different regime with its own expectations of the board.
The mistake is to assume that general business experience is enough, or that regulatory matters can be left to the compliance function. Regulators increasingly expect boards to understand and challenge the firm’s compliance with its obligations, and some board roles carry personal regulatory accountability. A NED who cannot tell when the company is drifting out of line with its regulatory obligations is not in a position to oversee it.
The answer is a proper induction that covers the regulatory framework, ongoing training as rules change, and regular briefings from the heads of compliance and risk. Our hub on FCA-regulated board governance covers the financial services regime, and our page on NED induction, training and development explains what boards should provide.
Mistakes and the Habits That Prevent Them
| Mistake | Protective habit |
|---|---|
| Relying on management assurance | Ask for evidence, and for independent assurance on key risks |
| Not reading the papers properly | Block reading time and write questions in advance |
| Failing to record concerns | Ask for your concern and the answer to be minuted |
| Ignoring culture | Look at staff data and spend time with people below the executive team |
| Mishandling conflicts | Declare interests at the start of every meeting |
| Taking on too much | Keep a capacity budget with a reserve for crises |
| Not understanding the regulatory regime | Ask for a regulatory briefing as part of induction |
Jodie says
References reveal these habits
When we take references, chairs often comment on exactly these habits: whether the director came prepared, asked the difficult question and declared interests properly. They are what builds a reputation on boards.
Jodie Garrington, Partner, NED Capital
The Mistakes Behind the Mistakes
Underneath the seven mistakes sit a few deeper causes that are worth recognising.
Losing independence of mind. Over time, a NED can become so close to the executive team that challenge starts to feel disloyal. That drift is gradual and hard to notice from the inside. It is one reason the Code treats long tenure as a factor that may affect independence, and why our article on why UK companies need independent non-executive directors stresses independence of judgement as well as formal independence.
Mistaking harmony for good governance. A board where everyone agrees can feel effective, but it may simply be a board where no one is asking the hard questions. Our guides to constructive tension in the boardroom and avoiding groupthink when selecting NEDs look at how boards guard against this.
Treating the role as an executive job. Former executives sometimes make the opposite mistake: getting too involved in operational detail and trying to manage rather than oversee. The shift in mindset is discussed in from executive to non-executive: the real shift in mindset.
When Avoiding Mistakes Is Not Enough
Sometimes a director does everything right and the board still does not respond. Concerns are recorded but not acted on, information continues to be withheld, or the director discovers something that cannot be reconciled with their duties. In that situation, the question becomes whether to stay or go. Our guides to when a NED should walk away from a board appointment and knowing when it is time to step down cover that decision, and our guide to what insurance non-executive directors need explains the protection worth checking before you accept any role.
A Simple Self-Check
Before each board meeting, it is worth asking yourself a few questions:
- Have I read the papers properly, including the appendices that matter?
- What am I being asked to accept on management’s word, and how could I test it?
- Is there anything I am uneasy about that I have not yet said in the meeting?
- What have I seen or heard about the culture since the last meeting?
- Are my declared interests up to date?
- Do I have the time to do this role properly at the moment?
- Is there any regulatory change I should understand before the next meeting?
None of these questions is complicated. Asked consistently, they prevent most of the mistakes described above. Board evaluations are another opportunity to test whether directors are falling into these habits, as explained in our guide to how board effectiveness reviews work.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most common mistake non-executive directors make?
Relying on management assurance without testing it is probably the most common. Executives are usually not being dishonest, but they are close to the business and naturally optimistic. A NED should ask how management knows what it is reporting, and use independent sources of assurance such as internal audit and the heads of control functions.
Can a non-executive director be held liable for governance mistakes?
Potentially, yes. Under the Companies Act 2006, NEDs owe the same general duties as executive directors, including the duty to exercise reasonable care, skill and diligence. Liability depends on the circumstances, but failing to read papers, test assurances or act on obvious warning signs can fall short of that standard.
Should a NED insist that concerns are minuted?
Yes, if a significant concern cannot be resolved in the meeting. The UK Corporate Governance Code expects unresolved concerns to be recorded in the minutes, and the minutes are the evidence of what the board considered. Asking for a concern to be minuted is part of the role, not a sign of hostility.
How many board roles can a NED safely hold?
There is no single number. It depends on the size and complexity of each company, whether you chair or sit on committees, and how much capacity you keep for a crisis. The UK Code expects directors to have sufficient time for their responsibilities and boards to approve additional significant appointments in advance.
Do NEDs need to understand regulation if the company has a compliance team?
Yes. The compliance function supports the board but does not replace its oversight. NEDs should understand the main regulatory obligations that apply to the business and be able to challenge whether the company is meeting them. In regulated sectors some board roles also carry personal regulatory accountability.
How can a board help its NEDs avoid these mistakes?
By providing a thorough induction, timely and well-structured papers, access to people below board level, ongoing training, a clear process for declaring conflicts and a regular evaluation that looks honestly at how each director contributes.
Related Guides and Services
Strengthening how non-executive directors oversee the board.
Oversight
Doing the Job Well
→ Why Governance Failures Happen
→ Reading the Board Pack
→ How Many Roles Is Too Many?
For Boards
Recruiting Well
→ Non-Executive Director Recruitment
→ Independent NED Recruitment
→ When to Walk Away
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Sister practice of FD Capital
Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director with more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept.
Strengthening Your Board?
Call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk to talk confidentially about appointing a non-executive director, or register as a candidate. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
NED Capital | Part of FD Capital Group | Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of NED Capital and a Fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name. He holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London, and has more than 25 years at C-suite level, working with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect businesses with the independent Non-Executive Directors they need to provide challenge, governance and strategic oversight — and personally leads candidate assessments for board-level appointments.