Family businesses are among the most resilient companies in the UK. They tend to take a long view, hold strong values and keep a close connection with their employees and communities. But they also face a governance challenge no other company faces in quite the same way: family, ownership and management overlap, and relationships that began at the kitchen table carry on into the boardroom. When decisions are shaped by family history rather than business logic, or when no one can comfortably challenge a family member, the business is exposed.
A well-designed board is one of the most effective ways to manage that overlap. This guide is about how to build one. It assumes you have already decided your business would benefit from outside board members. If you are still weighing that question, start with our article on whether private and family businesses need a non-executive director, which covers the decision itself. Here we focus on design: what the board is for, who should sit on it, how it relates to the family, and how it supports succession.
Start by Separating Three Things: Family, Ownership and Management
Most family business governance problems come from blurring three different roles. A widely used way of thinking about family firms describes them as three overlapping circles: the family, the owners and the business. One person may sit in all three, as a family member, a shareholder and the managing director. Another may be a family member and shareholder with no role in the business. A third may be a senior manager with no family tie and no shares.
Each circle needs its own forum:
- The family needs somewhere to discuss family matters: values, communication, who may work in the business, and how the next generation is prepared. In larger families this is often a family council or family assembly.
- The owners need a way to exercise their rights as shareholders: approving the strategy at the highest level, appointing the board, agreeing dividend policy and deciding whether to sell. This is governed by the articles of association and, usually, a shareholders’ agreement.
- The business needs a board of directors to set strategy, oversee management, manage risk and hold executives to account, whether they are family members or not.
The board’s job is to govern the business in the interests of the company. Under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006, directors must act in the way they consider most likely to promote the success of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, having regard to employees, customers, suppliers and the long term. That is not the same as doing what one branch of the family wants. Making that distinction clear, in writing and in practice, is the foundation of a family business board that works. Our guide to what corporate governance is explains the wider principles.
What the Board Is For
Before choosing people, agree what the board should do. In a family business, the board typically needs to:
- Set and review the strategy, with an honest view of the risks and of the capital the family is willing to commit.
- Appoint, support and hold to account the chief executive and senior team, including family members in executive roles.
- Oversee financial performance, controls and risk, so the family has confidence in the numbers.
- Plan for succession in leadership and on the board itself.
- Provide a professional forum for decisions that are hard to take within the family, such as executive pay for family members, dividend levels or whether to bring in outside investment.
Writing a short board charter or matters reserved for the board helps here. It sets out which decisions belong to the board, which belong to the shareholders and which are delegated to management. Our guide to board structure, composition and independence covers the options in more depth, and how to build a board from scratch covers the practical first steps.
Getting the Balance Right Between Family and Independent Directors
The central design question is the balance between family directors and independent outsiders. There is no single right answer, but there are clear failure modes at each extreme.
- A board made up entirely of family. This can work while the family is small and aligned, but it lacks outside perspective, and no one is in a position to challenge a family member without it becoming personal.
- A board where the family feels outnumbered. If outsiders dominate and the family feels its voice is no longer heard, the commitment and long-term thinking that make family businesses strong can be lost, and the family may resist the board altogether.
Most family businesses settle somewhere in between: family representation that gives the owners a real voice, with enough independent directors to make challenge normal rather than exceptional. A useful starting point for many is one or two independent non-executives alongside the family and executive directors, increasing as the business grows or as ownership spreads across more family members. A board skills matrix helps identify which gaps the independent directors should fill.
The Independent Chair
For many family businesses, the most important single appointment is an independent chair. A chair from outside the family can run board meetings impartially, manage disagreements between family members, act as a sounding board for the chief executive, and be the one person whose job is to make the board work for the company rather than for any branch of the family.
An independent chair is particularly valuable when:
- leadership is passing from one generation to the next and the outgoing leader needs a respected peer to work with during the transition;
- ownership has spread across several family branches with different interests;
- there is tension between family members working in the business and those who are shareholders only;
- the business is preparing for outside investment or a sale.
Where the family wants to keep the chair role, an alternative is to appoint an independent non-executive as a senior independent director, giving the board a recognised independent figure who can lead on matters where the chair is conflicted. Our guides to appointing a board chair and appointing a senior independent director cover both routes.
Choosing Independent Directors Who Suit a Family Business
Not every experienced non-executive suits a family business. The best fits combine the usual qualities of a strong NED with a particular temperament. Look for people who:
- respect the family’s values and long-term perspective, rather than treating the business like a quarterly-reporting company;
- can challenge family members firmly and privately without damaging relationships;
- are comfortable with informality where it is appropriate, and with formality where it is needed;
- bring specific expertise the business lacks, often finance, international growth, acquisitions, digital or people leadership;
- are genuinely independent, with no long-standing personal friendship with the family or financial dependence on the business.
The last point is easy to overlook. Many family businesses first appoint a trusted adviser, such as the long-standing accountant or a family friend. These people can be valuable, but they are rarely independent, and they may find it hard to challenge the family. A proper search, rather than an appointment from within the family’s circle, usually produces a stronger independent director. Our guide to appointing your first non-executive director walks through the process.
Family Councils, Shareholder Agreements and the Board
As a family grows, the board cannot carry every family conversation. Larger family businesses often formalise the other two circles.
The family council
A family council is a forum for the family, not a governance body for the company. It is where the family discusses values, communication, education of the next generation, and policies such as who may work in the business and on what terms. Keeping these discussions out of the boardroom protects the board’s focus on the business and gives the family a proper place to be heard.
The shareholders’ agreement and family charter
A shareholders’ agreement sets out the owners’ rights: how directors are appointed, which decisions need shareholder consent, dividend policy, and what happens when a shareholder wants to sell or dies. Many families also adopt a family charter or constitution, a non-binding statement of the family’s values and policies. Together these documents reduce the scope for disputes and give the board a clear framework. They should be drafted with specialist legal advice.
The board, the family council and the shareholders each need to know where their remit ends. Clear boundaries are what stop family disagreements from becoming board crises.
Start a board search
Building a Board for a Family Business — 0203 137 2496
Non-executive directors, chairs, committee chairs and trustees for boards across the UK. We reply within one working day, and shortlists typically follow within two to three weeks of an agreed brief. Email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk, or meet us at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF or Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
Succession: The Board’s Most Important Family Business Task
Succession is where family businesses most often struggle, and where a good board adds most value. It covers several distinct questions: who will lead the business next, whether that should be a family member or an outside appointment, how ownership will pass between generations, and how the board itself will be refreshed.
Independent directors are particularly helpful in leadership succession because they can assess family and non-family candidates on merit, without the emotional weight that family members carry. They can also help the outgoing leader step back gradually and give the successor space to lead. Our guides to board succession planning and board recruitment and succession planning cover the process, and why succession planning fails without NED oversight explains the common pitfalls.
The Wates Principles for Larger Family Businesses
Larger private companies, including many family businesses, have a legal duty to report on their corporate governance. Under the Companies (Miscellaneous Reporting) Regulations 2018, companies above certain size thresholds must include a statement in their directors’ report on which corporate governance code, if any, they apply and how. Many use the Wates Corporate Governance Principles for Large Private Companies, published by the Financial Reporting Council.
The Wates Principles cover purpose and leadership, board composition, director responsibilities, opportunity and risk, remuneration, and stakeholder relationships and engagement. Even for family businesses below the reporting thresholds, they are a sensible, proportionate framework for building a board, and they emphasise an effective chair and an appropriate balance of skills, backgrounds and independence.
Common Mistakes When Building a Family Business Board
- Appointing friends as “independent” directors. Long-standing advisers and friends rarely provide real challenge.
- Bringing family disputes into the boardroom. Without a family council or other forum, the board becomes the place where family arguments play out.
- A board with no real authority. If every significant decision is still taken over the family dinner table, independent directors will soon disengage.
- Leaving succession too late. Many boards are formed in response to a crisis rather than in good time.
- No clear terms for family members in the business. Pay, roles and accountability for family executives should be set by the board on the same basis as for anyone else.
How NED Capital Helps Family Businesses
We help family businesses appoint independent non-executive directors and chairs who understand family ownership and can work with it. That starts with helping the family and the existing board agree what the board needs, and then running a search that reaches candidates beyond the family’s own network. Searches are run by our senior search team under founder Adrian Lawrence FCA. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, so we can also help with finance directors and senior executives where a family business is professionalising its management. See our pages on private company board member search and how we recruit a non-executive director.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many independent directors should a family business board have?
There is no fixed number. Many family businesses start with one or two independent non-executives alongside family and executive directors, adding more as the business grows or ownership becomes more widely spread across the family.
Should a family business have an independent chair?
Not always, but it is often valuable, particularly during a generational handover, where ownership is spread across several branches of the family, or when preparing for outside investment. An independent senior independent director is an alternative where the family keeps the chair.
What is the difference between a family council and a board?
A family council is a forum for the family to discuss family matters such as values, communication and the next generation. The board of directors governs the company, sets strategy and oversees management. Keeping them separate protects both.
Do the Wates Principles apply to family businesses?
Larger private companies above the reporting thresholds must state which governance code they apply, and many use the Wates Principles. Smaller family businesses are not required to, but the principles are a helpful framework for any private company board.
Can a family member be an independent director?
Generally not. Independence means having no relationships that could affect judgement, and a close family tie to the owners is exactly that kind of relationship. Family members can of course be valuable non-executive directors, but not independent ones.
When should a family business build a formal board?
Ideally before it is forced to. Common triggers include growth, the approach of a generational handover, family members joining or leaving the business, outside investment, and preparation for a sale.
Related Guides and Services
Building boards for private and family companies.
Getting Started
Your First Board
→ Do Family Businesses Need a NED?
→ Building a Board From Scratch
→ Appointing Your First NED
Board Leadership
Chairs and Succession
→ How to Appoint a Board Chair
→ Appointing a SID
→ Board Succession Planning
Adrian Lawrence FCA — Founder, NED Capital
Fellow of the ICAEW | Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate | Sister practice of FD Capital
Adrian holds a BSc from Queen Mary College, University of London and is a former listed-company Finance Director who has worked with boards, investors and business owners across the UK. He founded NED Capital to connect organisations with the independent non-executive directors they need, and oversees the senior search team that runs every board mandate we accept. Read Adrian’s profile.
Building a Board for Your Family Business?
Whether you are appointing your first independent director or an independent chair to see the business through a generational handover, call 0203 137 2496 or email recruitment@nedcapital.co.uk for a confidential conversation. NED Capital is part of FD Capital Group, five specialist recruitment firms, with offices at 167–169 Great Portland Street, London W1W 5PF and Watling Court, Orbital Plaza, Cannock WS11 0EL.
NED Capital | Part of FD Capital Group | Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW practising certificate holder